Can you tell the sex of these chicks at 5 weeks?

[PeachygirlGA]

Ok, here's a pic of all 3. Their dad is a Buff Orpington and the mother of the one on the left is a red and the mother of the other 2 is an easter egger.


Now individually: Chick #1


chick #2 - this is the largest of the 3 and most resembles the buffs.


and chick #3 - you may notice this one has a crooked beak. When I did the feather testing at 1 day old this one had the straight accross feathers indicating a male I think. But I'm not real sure about that test!

Any help is appreciated!

 

[azcook]

TOTALLY GUESSING!!!!! I am a newbie But here are my assumptions
1.hen
2. rooster
3. hen

I would like to hear what other people think!

 

[PeachygirlGA]

Well, I was hoping for some educated guesses! lol! JUST KIDDING! I do appreciate your reply. I'm kind of a newbie too. After looking at the easter egger post I'm thinking mine might be all female because I really don't see much differences in them except for their coloring. Maybe somebody else can help me?

 

[PeachygirlGA]

Ok, so roughly 30 people have looked at the pictures but only one reply. Does this mean you can't tell or what? lol!

 

[azcook]

Well, I was hoping for some educated guesses! lol! JUST KIDDING! I do appreciate your reply. I'm kind of a newbie too. After looking at the easter egger post I'm thinking mine might be all female because I really don't see much differences in them except for their coloring. Maybe somebody else can help me?

absolutely NO educated guesses from me!!!!! the only reason I think the middle one might be a rooster is in the pix the legs look thicker, its tail feather look like the "stand" different and its comb is pinker (not red though) then the others...

 

[Rorporp23]

I think 1 and 2 are roos because of the size of their combs but I could be wrong.