Quote:
This is exactly the type of thing us old timers want to avoid.. It is NOT gospel that hay is bad for chickens.
This poor person is very new to chickens and she believes without a doubt that hay is bad..
I have used hay as a substitute for straw since 1966.. Never had an impacted crop.. You are not going to convince me that I have been extremely lucky.. I say if you had impacted crop, there were probably other problems that helped cause it.. You were extremely unlucky..
I give my chickens hay as a treat several times a month.. the only reason I do not use it for deep litter bedding is because it mats down and is too hard to clean in the spring... No, I do not clean out my coops every day.. I never clean them at all from fall until spring..
You have experienced different things than I have, and many, many others on BYC - if you search, you will see pictures of impacted crops - clogged with hay. If you've had good luck using hay - then good for you, carry on - we all do what works best for us. However, it's good to know the POSSIBILITIES. It's not just a random person who has had the issue - as I said, do a search, not only here, but on the 'net - ask avian vets, your chicken mentor, whoever you respect.
I have personally taken a hen to an avian vet for disgnosis - crop stasis due to impacted crop from HAY. She flushed it out; hen died anyway, due to crop statis, brough on by the hay impaction. I'm not making it up. Anyone can do whatever they like - I am only stating my personal experience, but folks - please research it before using hay. JMO.
Good options for nest boxes: shredded newspapers, though they can be messy. I believe wood shavings are best. I put a square of indoor/outdoor carpet in the bottoms of my nest boxes, and then shavings on top. Many folks use straw or hay - it that's what flicks your Bic, then do so. Just know that you have choices.
First of all, thank you jvls1942 for sharing your experiences with me. I understand that the hay rule isn't a sticky. That some chickens fare well with it and others don't. But that's why I asked. I want to know of other peoples' experiences because I don't have any. So far, my flock is very healthy and very happy from what I can tell.
Wynette - Thanks for your advice as well. I like the rug and shavings idea. I never thought of using rug but I bet it would save me a lot of hassle and would actually make cleaning easier.
I think after reading both of your responses, I'm going to start with the rug and alternate between the shavings and hay to see which one the chickens handle better. Afterall, they are the ones with the final say LoL because I'll be honest, I spoil them horribly.