Al, Jim, and others I’m going to disagree with you. Not everyone needs show quality chickens. Not everybody needs a dog that can take a prize at the Westminster Kennel Club Show. Not everyone needs a chicken that can take a Grand Championship at Ohio Nationals.
I think top quality show chickens are a waste for most people. For their goals, hatchery chickens are fine. I’m not arguing with you on the difference in quality and I admire your passion for your breeds. And I am not arguing about what people say, do, or know about chickens. But if you don’t have that passion, you don’t need them. Besides, without that passion to learn what to do and spend the time and money to do it right, if you start with show quality chickens without carefully and knowledgeably selecting the breeders, you’re back to hatchery quality chickens in a very few generations. Just from playing with genetics in my little flock, I think I can appreciate how hard it has to be to keep a flock of chickens show-quality.
I consider my parents and their parents about as old-timer as you can get. They raised chickens for meat and eggs to feed their families. They did not care about eye color, how pretty the feathers were, or any of that. They did not feed their chickens anything unless there was snow on the ground, then they would shell some corn and toss it to them. When I was a kid that was my job. Every four or five years in late spring, Dad would pick up a dozen hatchery chicks at the co-op, raise them for maybe three weeks in a cardboard box on the back porch with a bare incandescent bulb for heat and feeding them corn meal, then just turn them loose down at the coop. They lived (at least most of them did), they learned to forage for their food, and his next rooster came from those chicks. I was not aware of any show-quality chickens on any neighbor’s farm, but they all had a flock of chickens.
For some people it is important. Some people will spend thousands of dollars for a purebred dog that they never intend to show. Some people may show them or train them to work at specific tasks. I get my mutts at the pound. They chased an armadillo away from the house last night. Woke me up doing it to, but when I saw what it was I went back to bed. Some people want show-quality chickens for their own reasons. That is their business. But just because you have a passion for show chickens does not mean that everyone does.