Update:
I had also posted a pic in a fb group I'm in. Just a "boys or girls" post, no details. The seller reached out to me on their own before I had a chance to contact them. They were super concerned with making it right. When I got them originally, they had 3 month and 5 month pullets in one pen. My theory is that they were 3 month cockerels, but looked like the 5 month girls. They seller made it right immediately and gave me 2 laying hens that I got to choose. They just didn't want the boys back. I would use them again, they were really decent and really concerned about making it right. It makes me happy that not everyone is out to get you, because i have had that experience. Thanks for all the comments and help guys.