consistently getting soft shelled eggs

Chicken Canoe,

Yes, the balance of nutrients needs to be correct...but differentiation within my would be necessary because I have 1 hen, that lays this egg, out of my small flock of 7. All other shells are perfect. Well an occasional egg with a band, I assume while the hen waits for her favorite box and I have a flock of nest box loungers... and one or two off shapes from my bantam pullets...understandable. Shells are very strong though.

I read an article, while researching other issues, I'm just not going back for it (I am doing way to much research and I need a break.) where it mentioned in passing that a manganese deficiency while growing will cause a hen to lay thin shelled eggs. I don't remember if this was forever because the shell gland did not develope properly or if it could be corrected.

Leads me to put on my scientist coat....and wonder, how did my one hen have this deficiency when she was raised in the same environment as 3 others I have? Genetics? Or was it a disease that damaged her shell gland? Or does she have an ongoing low grade infection of some sort? Hmmmm....

I will find out what whole food has a whole bunch of manganese and try that. As well as phosphorous etc. I will try worming, and Corid, I will try natural anti-inflammatory and detox herbs.

She is fit and well otherwise, and quite a prolific layer of these special eggs.

When it's a whole flock...I would wonder also about a disease that may have moved through, and also some type of deficiency. Trying one thing at a time.


ETA... no reason to cull here, I would maybe see if her offspring had the same issue, then I would know about the genetic part...

If the eggs don't have thin spots, we eat them. If they are dinged or have translucent spots, the dog gets them over her food or microwave them for the chickens. The dog's coat is very shiny and not sheddy :) And a great chicken treat.
 
Last edited:
Try feeding them calcium, such as oyster shell. You can get a 50 pound bag for not much. Put a dish out there and if they need it, they'll take it. It will improve their shells with the calcium and make their shells nice and strong. Good luck
1f600.png
 
Last edited:
Um.. I think we can all agree we have oyster shell, it is out there free choice all the time. I also just have just the one chicken that lays soft shelled/no shelled eggs. :( went back to basics, no change so far.
 
Same here, oyster shell available at all times. I've only had 2 no shell eggs since they started laying March 10th. And they were a month apart.
 
Suzie's sounds kinda normal, since they just started laying. And after all of my reading, it seems it does just happen occasionally. Hey humans have ALL KINDS of ovulation, pregnancy issues that are pretty normal (just because we are biological creatures and things go amiss) so certainly do chickens.

Cluckies, What kind of chicken is it, again? Mine is some kind of EE. She looks like part Silver Laced Wyandotte, Very Striking looking, with a black beard and green/grey legs. She's a big girl. Flighty.

I thought they were some kind of leghorn cross because they are great layers of blue green eggs, hers are light blue, it looks from you pick that yours are too.

Right now, I have 22 3 week old chicks (i think, it's really hard to count them omg) and 2 bantams in icu with a poisoning of some type or Marek's. So unless they are having an emergency....they are getting food and water and a couple of snacks, no experimental treatments in the past few weeks.

Maybe we can find "the thread of similarity" and solve the problem/mystery...
 
I should clarify that this is my hens 3rd year laying. I just purchased them the 1st of march and the started laying for me on the 10th. Thanks for trying to help figure this out.i feel better thinking that every once in a while could be normal.
 
Cluckies, What kind of chicken is it, again? Mine is some kind of EE. She looks like part Silver Laced Wyandotte, Very Striking looking, with a black beard and green/grey legs. She's a big girl. Flighty.
She is an EE, she is a big girl, not flightly though, she is clean faced, she has a black head. Her sister is also an EE, she quit laying in november and hasn't started back up yet, it is weird. All my other girls laying just fine.

She lays blue green eggs when they have a shell, mostly there is no shell, kind of like a water balloon. She is a very sweet girl, also very smart. here she is:

 
Oh Cluckies she is so pretty!!! Love her colors! EE's are so lovely looking I think :)

Mine have beards but weirdo combs...

Why I didn't think of the simple solution before, I don't know....probably because I am thinking of everything under the sun to try for my 2 sickies. I think I got it figured out now....

So why not a little antibiotics? You don't eat rubber eggs anyway.... Alot of mine go to the dog or cooked and back to the chickens because they have a tiny translucent spot.


It might be some little infection there. Like when humans have a bladder or urinary tract infection, you can still function pretty well, but maybe a bit uncomfortable???


I will be in contact with a vet Mon or Tues, I'll ask if they will prescribe something without seeing her...otherwise it will be oxytet. from the farm store. I don't know how I will get it to just her though, she won't come close to eat snacks with the others... I might have to squirt it into her mouth at night. Any other ideas?
 
Thank you Alibaba, she is a sweetheart. her name is "baby" as she still only peeps.

Well, I bit the bullet and i'm de-worming her (and the rest of the flock, they are 1 year old, never been wormed) I've tried everything else. I'm thinking maybe if she is carrying a heavy worm load they may be eating up all her nutrition so she is unable to lay good eggs? Along with the other one who hasn't started laying yet since november? To clarify, i've not seen any worms, but...

I'm using safe-guard liquid 10% suspension goat de-wormer, 3/4cc, I'm on day 3 of a 5 day run. It is not fun! It is a wrestling match! I'll let you know how it goes. I hope to see an improvement in the egg shell quality for her in a couple of weeks if this is the issue. If it is not the issue, not sure what my next step will be. I don't want her to die if she gets infection from one breaking inside her
sad.png
Good luck everyone, if you find something that works, let us know (even if you are a lurker)!
smile.png
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom