Everythng matters...
But, did your suppplier SAY they all came from the same breeders?
I mean, at worst they are probably half-siblings...if colony bred, maybe even far relations.
If you had eggs from a single pair, you could not accumulate more than 7 or so before having to set them anyway...let alone the time spent in shipment.
So, two or three dozen collected over a day or so would almost insure some diversity.
To maintain TRUE genetic diversity, however, you would need to keep 30 to 50 breeding males anyway. Almost nobody does that (maybe largely the reason behind the decline of the A&M White standard since texas A&M got out of the business)?
Still, buying eggs from various sources would give you the additional genetic pool if you are in it for the long term. (For immediate eggs or meat, does not really matter. Keep in mind they usually lay best in their first year.)
Bottom line, save the best ones if you are breeding, maybe get some eggs from a different source a little later to mix in.
RBar
Quote: