i just want to second what red said
"When you reward the dog for coming to you, there is no reward unless you are holding the collar. When feeding the treat to the dog, the hand feeding the treat must have the wrist touching your body. When you use this little reminder, it stops you from reaching out to the dog, it makes the dog come all the way in to you to get the food, and you can then get the collar."
make sure you have her leashed/hand on her collar BEFORE she gets that treat...
"When you reward the dog for coming to you, there is no reward unless you are holding the collar. When feeding the treat to the dog, the hand feeding the treat must have the wrist touching your body. When you use this little reminder, it stops you from reaching out to the dog, it makes the dog come all the way in to you to get the food, and you can then get the collar."
make sure you have her leashed/hand on her collar BEFORE she gets that treat...
