I guess I need to figure out the bantam situation...how many to buy, should they be housed with the egg layers and moved to baby making pen when they're needed, etc. Any suggestions on the type of bantam to buy to do this job?
Bantams often do fine living with other breeds of chicken. But once a hen goes broody, some can be moved to another pen and some can not. It might make sense to have a pen where the bantams live, that has nestboxes you can separate a bit from the rest of the pen (maybe each nestbox is in a cage with a door, and you leave the doors open except when a hen is broody.)
There are two main reasons for separating a broody hen:
--she may come off the nest for breakfast, but then go sit on a different nest and let her original eggs get cold. (If she eats & drinks in a cage attached to her own nest, she cannot go back to the wrong nest afterward. She does need enough space to get off the nest, so she doesn't poop on the eggs.)
--other hens may lay eggs in her nest (bad if they are not the kind of egg you want hatched. Also bad if they are many days later than the ones you do want her to hatch, because you don't want a half-developed eggs left behind when the rest hatch and the hen takes the chicks off the nest to find food & water.)
For bantams, I would suggest you try an assortment of Old English Game Bantams from Ideal Poultry. I've had good results with several different colors of those. Buying the assortment will be a bit cheaper than picking specific colors, although of course you could pick specific colors if you want. If you watch the weekly specials, you can sometimes get a better-than-usual price. They only come in straight run, so about half will be males. Use the males for some of your first butchering experiments. Bantam leg/thigh pieces work nicely in recipes meant for chicken wings. Or they'd make cute little roasted chickens, like single-serving Thanksgiving turkeys.
It's convenient to have a variety of colors so you can easily tell the broodies apart (the black one has eggs just about to hatch, while the wheaten one just started, is easier than having to check legbands, or see which one has the funny crinkled comb or whatever other way you might tell same-color birds apart.)
Many people recommend Silkies or bantam Cochins for hatching eggs. I have a personal dislike of feathered feet (they always seem to be muddy), which rules out both breeds for me. Also, the crest on a Silkie can make it hard for her to see, which makes her more likely to be bullied by other chickens.
Old English Game Bantams don't need any special care, except that a covered pen is a really good idea. They fly even better than Leghorns, and much better than heavy breeds of chickens.
Broody means that they will sit on the eggs, or in the egg laying box, for long periods of time, as if she was incubating. I will only know if one of the is broody by noticing them laying in the boxes, right?
Yes.
Are you saying that if there is a broody hen in the flock I get, she will tend to remain broody throughout the year?
No.
For some hens, they will go broody one time in the spring, and that's it. They hatch eggs and raise chicks, then act like any other chicken for the rest of the year. Or they sit on the nest for a month or so, don't hatch chicks, and give up until next year.
For some other hens, they go broody several times each year.
I've had some that would lay about a dozen eggs, then go broody. After they hatched the eggs and raised the chicks, they would lay another dozen eggs and go broody again. This got repeated from early spring until late fall. (Some of those hens were Old English Game Bantams from Ideal Poultry, which is why I suggest you try that breed.)
My plan is to raise all the chicks, separate into two pens of 15 each, and get the egg laying production underway. I'll have a rooster and at some point when they are of age, I'll take one or two and move to a pen with a rooster to start making more chicks.
If you want to hatch eggs only from those specific hens, that will work fine.
But if you are happy to hatch eggs from any of the hens, just let the rooster live in one hen-pen all year long.
When a hen goes broody, grab the right number of eggs laid that day in the pen where the hens & rooster live, put those eggs under the broody hen, and expect chicks in 3 weeks.
My question is this...should I move the broody hen(s) to the rooster pen so that she can have chicks, knowing she'll be a good mother and incubate?
No, that will not work at all.
Once a hen goes broody, she stops laying eggs. So you have to collect her eggs before she goes broody, or you have to give her eggs laid by some hen that is still laying.
Or just have the rooster with two hens, and then use the broody hen to incubate them even if they're not hers?
Yes, use the broody to incubate eggs that were laid by another hen.
But do not give her two eggs today, two tomorrow, and two the next day.
Collect the correct number of eggs (store them in your house if needed), and give them all to the broody hen on the same day. If they all start incubating on the same day, the chicks will all hatch on the same day, which is good. That way the broody can switch to taking care of chicks, without leaving other eggs behind to get cold.
I'll have a baby making pen where all the magic happens, and an incubator pen where the broody hen or bantams will be for the incubation period. Want to keep separate because the roosters will be by themselves in the baby making pen, and figured the incubation pen will be nice and quiet so they can focus on being good mothers.
Don't leave the roosters alone in the baby-making pen. Put them in the pens with the laying hens. One rooster with 15 hens will be much happier than one rooster alone or two roosters together, and your life will be simpler because you have one less pen to tend each day.
I'm a newb, so no idea how long to keep until butchering, but that's why I came here...to learn from folks like you. So I will probably be doing as you suggested, keeping them 2-3 months and then butchering.
Different people do things different ways. The "right" age to butcher ranges from about 1.5 months up to 12+ months, depending on who you ask and what their goals are. 2-3 months is my own personal preference, but you may end up preferring a different age.
For your first batch, I would suggest you butcher one at some age (maybe 2 months), then wait a few weeks and butcher another, then later another... This will help you see the differences in chickens butchered at different ages, and then you can decide which way YOU prefer it.
Your last paragraph taking about broody hens being single parents...if the roosters stay in their own pen, and I bring in a bantam to incubate, is that a bad idea? Will they start knocking her up too?
I chose a silly way to say it, but I do not recommend putting the broodies in the same pen with the roosters. Yes, the roosters will try to mate with the broodies. That has a chance of breaking the eggs she is sitting on. Too much pestering by a rooster might make the hen give up on being broody.
Not sure if I should have ANOTHER small pen just for the bantams when they need to incubate, and keep roosters out of that...meaning put the hens in the rooster pen to make babies, and then move the eggs to the bantam pen so they incubate and separate from the roosters...or if it matters if they are staying with the roosters while sitting on the eggs for that period of time.
I would not have a rooster pen at all. Put the roosters in with the laying hens, and have a separate pen for the broodies.
How in the world can I free range such an operation? I need to keep them separate obviously, but also want them to free range a bit, get some natural food on their own, get some sun light, exercise, etc. Without creating some elaborate system where I corral them into certain pens when they come back, which would be a nightmare, not sure what to do. I'm thinking I'll just have to create a HUGE area that is a free range/run that's still fenced to keep them separate. Maybe a couple mobile tractor pens or something. Any ideas?
You could make one pen bigger, and put 30 hens/2 roosters in it (instead of trying to separate into two pens.) Then let those chickens free range during the day, and come back to sleep in that one pen at night. That way you won't have to sort them out into separate pens.
Then you could just leave the banties, broodies, chicks, and meat birds in their pens all the time. Runs attached to each of those pens can provide sunlight and exercise, although they won't get much natural food that way. For that matter, a big enough pen can provide room for some exercise inside, and windows can let in natural light as well.
I don't think this was mentioned yet, but the broodies that are raising chicks may need separate pens from each other. It's pretty common for a hen with chicks to attack any other hen or chick that comes near. Some mobile tractor pens might be a good solution here: after a batch of chicks are a few days old, so they can walk well, move them and their mother into a tractor. When the next batch of chicks hatch under a different hen, they & their mother will get moved into a different tractor. You may even keep the males in the tractors until you are ready to butcher them, rather than having a stationary pen for raising them for meat.