Everyone is 50/50 on whether this is a pullet or cockerel 😂

[bill3607]

It's okay....I just had a gut feeling he was a roo as a chick because he's always had such thick legs, even for a baby. I'm just devastated we can't keep him.

The thick legs made me wonder, but wasn’t sure it wasn’t just the picture, because they didn’t appear as thick in all pics.

You should start to see saddles coming in soon. You may can part it’s feathers now and see them

Unless it turns out to be a crowing pullet

 

[RiDaGeckoGuy]

I wish you the best luck I’ve had pulleys make similar noises to crowing

 

[Kiki]

Well well.
@EmmaRainboe Guess who was right this time.

 

[MACCanadianCoop]

Well I for one am disappointed that it's not a hermaphrodite bird. You could have formed a club

 

[bill3607]

Well I for one am disappointed that it's not a hermaphrodite bird. You could have formed a club

Oh, they’d be lined up to sign up, no doubt

 

[SwampPrincessChick]

You should start to see saddles coming in soon. You may can part it’s feathers now and see them

All chickens (except the Featherless, of course) have saddle feathers. The difference is that the males' are pointy and the females' are rounded.

 

[bill3607]

All chickens (except the Featherless, of course) have saddle feathers. The difference is that the males' are pointy and the females' are rounded.

Well, yes. I was talking obvious male saddle feathers

 

[EmmaRainboe]

Well well.
@EmmaRainboe Guess who was right this time.

I'd like more pics. I'm still not convinced.

 

[Kiki]

@TheNewFeathers Do you have a Youtube channel?

 

[TheNewFeathers]

The thick legs made me wonder, but wasn’t sure it wasn’t just the picture, because they didn’t appear as thick in all pics.

You should start to see saddles coming in soon. You may can part it’s feathers now and see them

Unless it turns out to be a crowing pullet

Sigh. I can't handle the back and forth.

That being said, I have an older hen that crows so it's a possibility for sure.

Here's some more photos. I tried to look for saddle feathers the other day and didn't see any yet.