Oh yes, I agree and I've "dun an gone off and selected some good 'uns too" I started out with some silver Phoenix and have crossed them onto some somewhat feral chickens(my swampers as I refer to them as) that I collected out of the Atchafalya River Basin years ago. They keep me in full supply dang near year round (sometimes to the point of being overwhelmed/inundated) with chicks.Broodiness is something that you need to select for. Our Dorkings are most broody in late-Spring. I want chicks in March--incubators. For early hatches, incubators are best. Silkie crosses are often praised for natural incubation.
For late spring hatches, dual-purpose breeds are appropriate. You can tempt early brooding by putting fake eggs in the nest. Sometimes it works.
There's a whole learning curve, and it actually takes a good few years of high volume to learn it fast, otherwise, it probably takes the better part of a decade. Eventually, one learns that broodies, especially in the first several weeks, should not be out with the rest of the flock.
The point that gets me in the broody question post is the fact that those hatchery stocks went broody. I may understand the Sussex doing so but the BR and the NH is very very rare for them to even come close to doing so from my experiences with those production influenced types. But to answer the ques it is not uncommon for those heavier breeds/dual purpose type to go broody during the hottest parts of the season I don't have the answer just much proof.
Jeff
Last edited: