I've enjoyed reading people's experiences with different breeds and glad this old thread has new life.
I began my chicken adventure several years ago just for eggs for my little family. We started with Easter Eggers (sold as "Americaunas" - but what did I know?) chosen for the egg colors of course because what could be more fun than finding blue, green and pink eggs in a nest when you're 6 and 2 years old? We lost all but one hen to fox, then added a few more and lost another couple so we had just 2 hens for about a year and a half; my lone survivor EE from my original flock and a SLW who joined her later on. This spring I decided it was time to add some more girls but I had trouble deciding on the breed/s; I hadn't become a member here yet but read an overwhelming number of breed reviews but just went with what I already knew. However, the day I went to pick up my 3 EE pullets, I ended up trading one out for a Golden Spangled Hamburg...a breed I had decided AGAINST due to the negative reviews I had read. I am so glad I didn't remember those reviews that day!
I never tire of watching my flock go about their day pecking around the yard and among the gardens but while the majority of the flock bathes in the flower beds, preens on the patio and lazes about in the sun, this little Hamburg never stops her search for tasty morsels and she eats what the others turn their beaks at. She prefers foraging over feed although she makes sure she's practically in my lap when I offer up the BOSS and she stakes out the wild bird feeder to fend off the squirrels from the falling seeds. She's also the one to call out the warnings when there's potential danger and when she hides, unlike her flockmates, she remains silent and perfectly still. She also flies quite well (I named her accordingly - Amelia Earhart) and I'm not one for clipping wings so they have as many means as possible to escape in the event of a predator attack while they're out ranging.
As for laying, she'll go for 8 to 10 days straight before having a day off. The only drawback is that her eggs are rather small (but so is she - though still LF) so when I bake, I use twice as many but that's not a problem for me and originating from Holland, she should do quite well during our winters.
Despite the bad reviews and initially deciding there was no way this was a breed for me, I've already ordered GSH chicks for this coming Spring and will be refining my flock down to these beauties and a DP Heritage breed (though that lone EE survivor is here for the long haul).