Quote:
Or how about Ranger?
Angel wing is more an issue of a lack of greens and too many carbohydrates (in my opinion) than too much protein.
Think about it. What do young wild waterfowl eat? Bugs, weeds and fish. They do NOT eat corn wheat and soy. Their natural diet is high in protein with lots of greens and low in sugars. Angel wing is very prevalent in duck populations where people are feeding ducks in park ponds. People are not feeding these ducks protein. They are giving them bread, pretzels, crackers and other carby garbage.
I feed my ducks game bird feed and they also get greens in their water bowl every morning as well as forage time in the yard each day.
That makes sense, but until there's some scientific research (yeah right. Like that'll ever happen), I'll stick to my "high protein is bad" thing.
I think people say that because some ducks can't go out and forage and get greens, so the higher protein isn't good because it can't even out with their foliage intake. My ducks were free ranging (with my goose) and the goose still got a touch of angel wing. Switched to food with lower protein and within three days it was gone.
But like I said, your theory (and they're all theories until someone takes the initiative to do a study) does make sense.
I think they coincide with one another even.
Since with no greens and higher protein levels they're more likely to form angel wing (broad statement)...
Feels like I need to do a study now.
But I couldn't bear to do that to my duckies! Lol
Hmm, I wonder how anybody would go about doing a study like that.
Edit:
And even if the "wild" ducks are in plentiful vegetation, if they're being fed sugary bread and other things, they'll look for any excuse to NOT eat their vegetables! I'm thinking that's why even 'free-ranging' "wild" populations tend to get angel wing if humans feed them...
You know, we don't feed the bears because they'll get tamer and tamer and start rummaging through human food and garbage, but we can feed wild ducks with no laws against that?!
Sheesh. The numbers get so high that disease is prevalent, and the bread decomposes in their water and such. Makes a horrible environment. THEN the worst part is, when the people stop feeding them, they don't know what to do and they all die off.
If only people knew enough not to mess with nature, we could HAVE ducks on our public ponds! With no problems if they weren't fed.
I mean, if you have to feed them, feed them grass! They love eating grass thrown into the water.
Or how about Ranger?
Angel wing is more an issue of a lack of greens and too many carbohydrates (in my opinion) than too much protein.
Think about it. What do young wild waterfowl eat? Bugs, weeds and fish. They do NOT eat corn wheat and soy. Their natural diet is high in protein with lots of greens and low in sugars. Angel wing is very prevalent in duck populations where people are feeding ducks in park ponds. People are not feeding these ducks protein. They are giving them bread, pretzels, crackers and other carby garbage.
I feed my ducks game bird feed and they also get greens in their water bowl every morning as well as forage time in the yard each day.
That makes sense, but until there's some scientific research (yeah right. Like that'll ever happen), I'll stick to my "high protein is bad" thing.
I think people say that because some ducks can't go out and forage and get greens, so the higher protein isn't good because it can't even out with their foliage intake. My ducks were free ranging (with my goose) and the goose still got a touch of angel wing. Switched to food with lower protein and within three days it was gone.
But like I said, your theory (and they're all theories until someone takes the initiative to do a study) does make sense.
I think they coincide with one another even.
Since with no greens and higher protein levels they're more likely to form angel wing (broad statement)...
Feels like I need to do a study now.
But I couldn't bear to do that to my duckies! Lol
Hmm, I wonder how anybody would go about doing a study like that.
Edit:
And even if the "wild" ducks are in plentiful vegetation, if they're being fed sugary bread and other things, they'll look for any excuse to NOT eat their vegetables! I'm thinking that's why even 'free-ranging' "wild" populations tend to get angel wing if humans feed them...
You know, we don't feed the bears because they'll get tamer and tamer and start rummaging through human food and garbage, but we can feed wild ducks with no laws against that?!
Sheesh. The numbers get so high that disease is prevalent, and the bread decomposes in their water and such. Makes a horrible environment. THEN the worst part is, when the people stop feeding them, they don't know what to do and they all die off.
If only people knew enough not to mess with nature, we could HAVE ducks on our public ponds! With no problems if they weren't fed.
I mean, if you have to feed them, feed them grass! They love eating grass thrown into the water.
Last edited: