I've had four pullets start laying this October (one might've been the last few days of September) and the final one from that age group laid her first egg on November 1st, when we were already down to less than nine hours of daylight.
How's the light pollution where you are?
Small things can add up. Proximity to a house, or street lights, etc. Pullets are more sensitive than hens.
Although it's termed pollution (due to the effect on wild birds, bees and other insects), if it works for your benefit re: eggs then it's a nice feature.
For a visual... Pretend the moon was near or all the way full, every night for at least a couple hours. Not all night. That's the light level that can trigger laying.
I suspect that it may be a lot of folks who don't realize how bright our evenings can really be, as we step out of our bright interior lit houses.
I know my mother is always asking me, "don't you need a flashlight?!" in the evening when I've been outside working since before sunset, but I say "No I can see everything and don't want to mess that up narrowed to just the one little area the flashlight will shine at a time" (ok, I don't use that many words
).My point is, there are a lot of variables that can affect your outcome. But the science itself stays the same.
@Ridgerunner
Either way people definitely have hope for eggs. Only a matter of time.
But what happens when people expect eggs in a specified number of months since hatch, look for them day after day, and they never show up? It's a bad hen, right? What a poor producer! Maybe she should go on the cull list.
But she's being controlled by factors affecting this whole spinning ball in space, and many other creatures on it.
So if you want eggs sooner, add some light. My solar string on a timer cost $25 on amzn.
