Thank you so so much for your opinions. I really hope you guys are right.
Both of them were bought to replace one of my original flock members that became egg bound. I'm already attached to them but would have to send them back if they were cockerels.
Girls. I know what the EE boys look like (I have 4--wanted girls) and these combs are totally different. Plus the dark one is all one color = girl. The one with the orange/red has a short tail = girl. One of my boys has a very similar tail to your dark one--I'm keeping him until he crows just to be sure.