Grubbly Farms vs. Scratch and Peck

[Jbyrd212]

Hi, all.

I am deciding between Grubbly Farms and Scratch and Peck feeds.

I have read both of the ingredient lists from top to bottom and Grubbly reads more favorable to me.
I am aware that they technically aren’t organic.

However, I have been recommended Scratch & Peck by multiple people.

I am seeking more advice on which to go with.

Thank you in advance for your resourceful responses and time.

 

[nuthatched]

What are your goals?

 

[Jbyrd212]

What ate your goals?

Just the highest quality feed. I desire something better than the current feed I have (Nutrena). USA, non-GMO, etc.

 

[thecatumbrella]

I've used both. I like the Scratch and Peck mash to make fermented feed (as an occasional treat), and I like that Grubbly uses insect larvae as a protein source. Grubbly also has really good customer service, in my experience.

 

[nuthatched]

Just the highest quality feed. I desire something better than the current feed I have (Nutrena). USA, non-GMO, etc.

You can get nongmo in nutrena, I think it's the Hearty Hen layer. Honestly, grubbly farms and scratch n peck are what is often considered 'boutique' brands, it's basic nutrition at a bougie price.

 

[Jbyrd212]

I've used both. I like the Scratch and Peck mash to make fermented feed (as an occasional treat), and I like that Grubbly uses insect larvae as a protein source. Grubbly also has really good customer service, in my experience.

I agree. And the only reason they aren’t certified organic is because something about what the larvae eats.
My adult hens love the grubbly treats. Their supplements look decent, too.

 

[Jbyrd212]

You can get nongmo in nutrena, I think it's the Hearty Hen layer. Honestly, grubbly farms and scratch n peck are what is often considered 'boutique' brands, it's basic nutrition at a bougie price.

I’ve been thinking that. The price tag is pretty hefty.

 

[Lrnadoon]

i have given my hens both and they prefer Grubbly farms. I mix Grubbly with Kalmbach organic feed that I get from Chewy. I like to mix the two because the ingredients are differerent and I like giving them a variety. Just thought I would put my two cents in!

 

[thecatumbrella]

The price tag is pretty hefty.

This is part of why I gave up on the nicer feeds. I like the concept, but my chickens would turn around and eat chunks of wood/styrofoam/hardware. So... you know. The flock has spoken. "Trash" food for the trash babies!

 

[Justagalwithchicks]

We use Scratch & Peck for a ferment and our chickens love it. Too pricey for everyday food in my budget