I bought from Cackle last year and didn't have any sexing issues but I did have the most health problems I'd ever had from a batch of chicks and I think it came down to poor genetics or unhealthy parents. My Appenzeller arrived missing a toe. I had a crested cream legbar that was off from the beginning and I put a ton of energy into saving. She ended up never being able to walk properly and with scissor beak. She had to be put down when she was about 9 months old from all her health problems. There was some other weirdness but I don't remember exactly what. I definitely don't want to scare you and my experience could have been a fluke but be sure to give your chicks a really good once over when they arrive.I’ve decided to go with cackle!
This year I went with Meyer and the chicks seem to come from better stock but I think I have a lot of sexing errors.
By the way, Buff Orpingtons are awesome chickens! They are my favorites in my flock
