Thanks everyone for the help! It sounds like #1 is the best based on the advice of body type and color. (I think I'll somewhat ignore the comb for now.) His color is definitely the best (darkest blue, clearest lacing) and his body type seems good, he just isn't quite as big as my other monsters... luckily though, the hens are very large, so I'm hoping that will help out the next generation. And I realized I have 3 splash hens, not 2, so I do have a bit more choice with them.