AllenK RGV
Chicken Addict
I never confine mine nor do I mess with closing the coop door. The do whatever they like whenever they like. The hawks fail miserably over and over they waste their time trying to poach my flock. The coyotes and other predators also have yet to get us probably because we have our chain link hurricane fence nailed down so they can't get under it.My birds hate not being free but I occasionally have to confine them due to hawks. While I sometimes have way too many birds it's always when I'm down to just small breeding flocks that a hawk will get one of my best hens.
I do have large runs and the bird netting has been effective at keeping the hawks out I'd prefer to free range them but sometimes don't have any to spare especially for free... So they get jailed...
Try tightening up the netting covering all holes, or maybe use heavy fishing line criss crossed at spots where it's not easy to enclose with netting?
I honestly think it might be about the breeds kept at this point. In my case most US raptors overwinter where I live we have Sumatras and they have done great!