I think all of the eggs are bad. I took two eggs away today. She still has two eggs. I feel so bad for her. What should I do? I thought about trying to find a baby chick for her. Would this help or is it best to just take away the eggs and have her get over it?
Since the eggs went all night without being set on, any chicks that would've been in them are dead! If you want chicks, you can give her a clutch of all of your chickens eggs to set...you said you have a Roo, so they should all be fertilized. Just put another 8 eggs under her from the other hens....try to make it from one day, or two at the most, so they will all hatch at the same time...or she could abandon the ones that don't hatch right away with the rest of them...two days worth of eggs is usually the best...it takes, usually 21 days to hatch...sometimes, with a broody, you might get some that hatch at 20 days...
Good luck!