Hen has rooster like tail feathers?

[Onyxflock]

They said, "We half-ass think that's a rooster, but we half ass think that's our green egg layer" They said they have a rooster return 100% guarantee--- now we're trying to decide if we want to keep him or return him for a hen....
Our girls are free range so there might be a benefit to having a rooster but it's also somewhat intimidating

The Rooster is best to keep for free ranging, especially if he's already docile with you. Keep on his good side and he'll take care of your girls. My 3 chicks turned out 1 rooster, just like yours, he got tail feathers first, then neck feathers. At first they all looked the same. He is really pretty.

 

[Ms Clucky]

I had a Bantam Cochin Frizzle Rooster that never grew spurs. Doughboy.