Greetings! It's exciting to read this excitement and consideration surrounding White Dorkings.
I can see the type in those flock pics of White Dorkings. I recognize the type as being representative of our strain. They're looking good.
Some quick thoughts that might help:
The big male with type issues: use him, pairing him with the best typed females possible. Use the others, too, though.
If you're receiving stock this year, raise everything you receive, and wait to see what you get. Even watching faults grow out teaches you something, even if it's why you don't let them grow out.
If you're workings with an established flock. Check chicks for color, comb, and toes. Cull anything but pure white, RC, and five perfectly formed toes. Also, the shape of the toes on day one is the shape of the toes at 6 months. You're not going to want to use a completely mangled toed bird; so, don't bother. Cull and keep hatching until you have out the number of chicks that you want. Also, remember that RCs comb with lots of easy to come by faults, males especially can be culled young for comb, certainly by broiler age. Therefore, you can hatch more males than you intend to grow out because you can drastically reduce their numbers for comb at, say, 13 weeks old if you want young spatchcocked broilers for the BBQ.
Look at the down, and if you see a black splotch, cull it. That black splotch is going to become black feathers, and when it comes down to it, you're not going to breed from a black feathered bird. A word on white, remember that white isn't a color. It's the masking of color. So all white birds are a color underneath, if you scratch the surface, usually birchen or cuckoo. Moreover, there is dominant white and recessive white both of which are present in YHF Dorkings. Occasionally on has some color seepage, no big deal, just cull it out. Try to never breed from a male that shows reddish seepage. It will lead to a dominance of the golden gene, which is unfortunately present in our strain, and it will lead to brassiness in cocks, which is a a serious defect.
Keep 'em hatching!