How I pick Chicken Breeds

As you said, personality. It's important but not #1.

For me, the #1 criteria for selecting a breed is choosing those that are most adaptable to one's climate.
A bird may be friendly but having Chanteclers or Orloffs in Texas or the tropics is a recipe for disaster. Or at least making management very difficult. Just as having Seramas or Cubalayas in Minnesota would be.

Other characteristics I find important in no particular order, like you, productivity, but also vigor, free ranging ability - which includes alertness, ability to avoid predators as well as good foragers.
Since I hatch a lot and have to cull a lot of roosters, meat quality is very important.
The breed I raise is so famous for flavor that they have their own foodie festival in Spain where people come to buy their Christmas dinner. Fira del Gall or Fair of the Rooster.

After 30 + breeds in multiple color varieties, I've found my favorite breed and you would likely hate them.
They are aloof and until they're a year old, avoid human contact to the extreme. That fear and wariness of anything not chicken is what keeps them alive while foraging without supervision.

A flock of orpingtons o,r heaven forbid, silkies wouldn't last long around here. With hawks, owls, coyotes, foxes, raccoons, opossums, neighbors' marauding dogs, weasels, mink, etc., those friendly breeds wouldn't live long.
I can turn out my flocks and leave fully expecting them to be there when I return. I haven't lost a bird to a hawk since having one of these roosters with a flock. I have lost a rooster to a coyote or dog on occasion but he saves the rest of the flock.

It's all about the personality of the owner as well as the chickens.

 

It's interesting reading the criteria that different members have in selecting their respective breeds. For me personally, the order goes like this:

1. Hardiness (this would include climate adaptability)--If a chicken doesn't survive all it's other characteristics are worthless.

2. Egg laying ability--the main reason that I raise chickens is for eggs. A small percentage of my breeds over the years have been chosen for their appearance, but the vast majority of them have been heavy egg producers.

3. Temperament--I would almost rank this one on an equal basis with egg laying ability. I want excellent layers, but not aggressive, high strung, or flighty birds (it's why I don't raise White Leghorns anymore despite the fact that they are egg laying machines). I don't want breeds in my flock that children can't handle.

4. Appearance--I want my chickens to at least look nice (with apologies to Naked Neck owners, it's why I've never had any of them in my flock, and never will). ) I've had a few breeds in my flock (Cochins, Silkies, Mille Fleur D'Uccles, Sebrights, Polish, etc.) solely for the way they looked even though they were poor layers.

Given all these criteria, Black Sex Links (Black Stars) are my personal favorite chickens. They are very friendly and hardy, egg laying machines and I personally think that the hens are quite beautiful in their black feathers with the copper or reddish colored feathers around their neck areas.

 

And it's interesting to see how one's personal criteria can change over the years. My flock today is so different than my flock 20 years ago.

When I started it was pretty much about the eggs. Sex links and brown Leghorns. Color was important to a degree, but not as much. Lots of eggs was my goal.

Then there was some breeding, and mixed breeds, and colorful egg baskets. Then there was the "eye candy" year or two where I ordered birds solely on pretty.

Now I have a pen of bantam cochins to use as broodies, and two silkies. 20 years ago I would have told you I'd never ever have a silkie. I have two, have had for 18 months, and will possibly sell them in the spring. Tried them, just not my thing.

So, from someone who was solely egg production based 20 years ago, I'm now feeding probably 45 birds.


I got 3 eggs last week.

 

Very interesting. I pretty much went the opposite direction over the past few decades. I used to have dozens of breeds, most of them chosen for their appearance as much as anything else. But I've become much more utilitarian over the years, reducing my flocks down mainly to productive egg layers.

 

Yes, I think egg production is important to 70+% of keepers.
After years with white leghorns, I dabbled in all the varieties I did to acquaint myself with as many breeds characteristics as I could with limited space and time.
It was fun having the gorgeous egg basket as well as the pasture eye candy.

 

I start my selection by egg color #1. I like colored eggs, especially blue. This helps me because I'm a chicken addict. It also helps because alot of colored egg layers are suitable for my climate, #2. Personality/broodiness is #3. I enjoy having and watching the different breeds interact with our farm. Color of feather is not so important to me yet... I have chickens for eggs and company not show at this point, so it's my #4.