How old are your hens? Are they also about a year old, and laying eggs, or are they this spring's pullets?
If they are mature enough to be laying eggs, they should be willing to be mated by a polite rooster. If he's actually too rough and hurting them, that's a black mark against him.
Some birds do have feathers that just don't hold up well. Do you have hens who look fine, and others who don't? Is this rooster concentrating on a couple of them only?
If he's actually too rough with his flock, that doesn't make him a winner either.
Mary
If they are mature enough to be laying eggs, they should be willing to be mated by a polite rooster. If he's actually too rough and hurting them, that's a black mark against him.
Some birds do have feathers that just don't hold up well. Do you have hens who look fine, and others who don't? Is this rooster concentrating on a couple of them only?
If he's actually too rough with his flock, that doesn't make him a winner either.
Mary