I created a thread several days ago by the title “this has me stumped” . It is about one of my 3 orpington hens that has a bald bulging non tender soft area beneath her vent. She has had it for months and it has me puzzled as to what is causing it. Plus poo sticks to it and that really bothers me. I got a lot of excellent comments and suggestions. One poster said to explore fatty liver syndrome. Which I did. I know one of the other chickens is obese. She doesn’t seem to eat any more than the others but she is fat just the same. One of the symptoms of a fatty liver is obesity. Plus decreased egg laying. She has not laid an egg since spring. Now this is not the hen that I originally posted about, it is a different one. Over a period of 4 years I have purchased 6 Orpington pullets. 2 at a time. I have lost 3 of them (not all at once) one died within the first year from coccoidosis. But this last spring and summer I have lost 2 I don’t know the actual cause and have taken them to vet to be treated, checked out, to get them well, and at an unbelievably high cost. But lost them anyway 3 months apart. This has ruined my summer and I have grieved over those chickens like you would not fathom. The first hen that died had just gotten apathetic, off her feed, had not laid an egg in several months. The first time I took her, the doctor said she had a bacterial infection. He gave her antibiotics and sent some home with me which I gave to her. She got better for a little while and then got worse again. I took her back to the vet, he said her lungs sounded bad. He gave her steroids and antibiotics home to give to her over a seven day period. Which I did. She did not get any better I took her back and she died in the vets office! That really set me back on my heels. The last one I lost was one of my favorites and has just devastated me. She had respiratory issues for a couple of years, and had been treated multiple times. The doctor never told me what the respiratory issue was and I was too stupid to ask him. He would just give me antibiotics, send her home and she would get better until she was stressed and then it would flare up again. This scenario was repeated several times over the last couple of years. The others seem to have respiratory problems as well. Not remotely close to extent that she did, but from time to time they sneeze and have a wet sounding “cluck. So, I have 3 chickens left. One who is obese, hasn’t laid in a couple of months. She may/may not have fatty liver. Another one has this strange growth beneath her vent. It is not open, not draining, no odor. The other hen, well I guess she would be considered overweight as well. I have come to realize that apparently I have been feeding them all wrong. , I give them treats, game bird food which is 23% protein, which is not the right thing to do. I only started doing that because I read on a chicken forum that 16% protein which is what the regular laying feed has and is the minimum protein that a bird needs. And that this person had been feeding his chickens game bird food since they were born and they were five years old. So I thought since I wanted them to be as healthy as possible I switched to this feed about two or three months ago. They have not gained any weight on this. They are all in the process of having a soft molt. I change their water every day, 2x a day in the summer. I alternate acv in water one day then 6 drops of oxine the next. I do give them oat and honey granola bars a day as a treat which I now know was probably one of the worst things I could do for them. I also give them a hand full of scratch a day, and a hand full of raw oats a day. So in reading all of the responses to the thread I started a week ago I must be an incompetent owner. Yet the family next-door has 12 chickens, they feed them table scraps every day, the cheapest rations, (they said -not my opinion) the chickens live in less than good conditions and are in a pen, while mine free range. They have not lost one single chicken. I have bought six and lost three. So this where I am. On the internet trying to find out what is wrong with my chickens for the last 3 hours. The cats are yowling to be fed, I have chores to do and I haven’t even let the girls out of their run. Hopefully they are all still alive