Yes, I completely understand how hard it is to make those decisions. I have 3 roos & keep changing my mind about the one that's leaving. After today, I certainly love all 3 for giving the warning & keeping the hens safe. They were hatched together & work as a team. At night, I just put them into the garage. They can crow all they want, but no one can hear them. I let them out around 8am after all the crowing is done. They have a hard time deciding whether to eat or mate 1st. I have a hard time not laughing at them.