This link has great article on the Ameraucana breeders website for anyone interested:
http://ameraucana.org/forum/index.php?topic=957.0
under "additional notes" at the bottom it says "These people are not necessarily being deceptive, rather uneducated about the breed." I'd like to believe this is true more than they are purposefully being deceptive.
I am a chicken novice, I have only had chickens for less that a year, yet I am continually floored by people who I think should know chickens, who have them, sell them and how little they actually know! Within 2 days of getting my chicks last year I knew that the store (not one of the big feed stores) had no clue what they were talking about. They told me that I had Rhode Island red chicks, "well actually golden comet but they are the same thing" Huh???? AND they said all 4 of my black chicks were barred rock - clearly 2 could not have been b/c of their markings. Okay, did not really matter to me, I just wanted chicks and I love them regardless of what they are!
You wonderful Indiana BYCers have educated me greatly. I wish I had found this sooner but it caused me to be more choosy this year. I do not need show quality birds. Yet I still I wish I could get all my chicks from Indiana breeders, and most will be. My only dilemma is that I have gotten nervous about getting all my chicks straight run. Depending on zoning laws I am getting 18-28 chicks this year. If zoning does not change, then the full number won't happen til next year. But that is a potential of half (or God forbid more!) of them being cockerels! So, the one chick I decided to bend on, and get from RK is the EEs. DD really wants some, they are the first chickens she fell in love with, and I find it it fascinating to not have a clue what they will look like and watch them grow up and feather out. I know chicken sexing is not a sure thing, but at least it gives me a better chance! I still may be rehoming some cockerels, with my full flock I'd like to have a couple. I miss our roo and his cock-a-doo (he left out the doodle).