Lexan is pretty expensive tho! We used to only sell it by a full sheet.
you could also go with a laminated glass. It's not too expensive, and a flat glass shop would probably sell you a little piece for next to nothing. Laminated has 2 pieces of glass with plastic sandwiched in between. It will be tinted to green lightly - it's what your car windshield is made of. You will find it nearly impossible to break all the way through.