Is it two roosters? If so, would that be a bad idea? (several pictures included)

Woods-Witch

In the Brooder
5 Years
Apr 14, 2014
16
1
22
Central California
Hi group. I have a question about roosters.

I bought three Delaware chicks awhile back with the hope that one might be a rooster and I could breed them at least once. The one confirmed female got sick and died. Of the two remaining, I'm 99.9% sure one is a rooster. I think the other one might be a male also but that depends on the day, season, weather conditions, time, astrological alignments ... etc. Some days I'm convinced he is a she and other days I'm dreading that she may be a he and it's making me crazy
barnie.gif
.

These two Del's are about five weeks old (the source has no idea when they were acquired but they did hatch on the same day). I think they're old enough for an educated guess at least. The 99.9% rooster is much bigger than the other Del, has a big red comb and is sprouting wattles. No crow yet but some raspy squawks--especially when he hears crows or hawks flying over--and he's already herding all the girls around like a pro with the exception of my top-of-the-totem-pole Speckled Sussex who pecks him if he tries to make her do anything (she's stubborn). He's also growing what looks like it could be be a pretty nice tail. He's not mean and was spoiled as a baby (still is). He eats out of my hand and he's probably going to be a great rooster. Now, the other one is different. He/she is much smaller, has no tail of any kind, and has a smallish pinky/red comb in comparison. He/she is not very dominant at all but will square off with the other Delaware if he gets too pushy and stands his/her ground. He/she isn't growing feathers very well compared to the other chicks. He/she also miraculously survived an illness and a broken leg simultaneously. That might be why the feathers are stunted. He/she was on death's doorstep multiple times and is now doing fine other than having a very subtle "funny walk" that most people don't notice until I tell them what to look for. In addition, this is my very favorite chicken. I am extremely attached, to put it mildly. He/she loves me, sits in my lap, runs up to my feet every time I go outside, tries to follow me into the house at bedtime every night ... etc.

I have ten chicks of varying but close ages, total. One is a rooster and one might be. It's too early to tell with my little Buff Orps. They all live in a big coop/enclosed run combo that will be expanded even more this Summer once I have all the potted herbs and landscaping I want for them growing well. I might let them free-range out back in the future but there is dense forest, a highway and there are lots of predators including bad dogs that worse neighbors don't control so it's a big maybe.

The first set of pictures are the 99.9% rooster. His name is Targaryen. The second set are he?/she? with no proper name yet. I call him/her Stumpy for now (hopefully it doesn't stick). There are also some pictures of the two together to show the contrast. Like I said, these two are the same age (around five weeks) and their sizes are very different. If I was comparing Stumpy to one of my other chickens I would think the comb seems pretty red. Compared to Targaryen though, it's not.

Soooo ... basically ... do I have two Delaware roosters? If so, should I or can I have two roosters?
fl.gif
Or will it be chaos and bloody fighting when they reach maturity? I know it depends on individual personalities but I'm just looking for overall likelihood at this point. I love them both but, if pressed, I'll pick Stumpy every time. I know Targaryen is much better looking (for now) and has all the makings of an excellent flock guardian but I could never let Stumpy go. Stumpy is my little miracle lap chicken.

Am I right about Targaryen being a rooster? Can anyone tell if Stumpy is a boy or a girl with any degree of certainty? If they're both roosters, is there any hope of managing my flock in harmony?

Thanks for looking and for any advice/thoughts.

- Woods Witch



Targaryen #1 (about 5 weeks):



Targaryen #2:




Targaryen #3:




Targaryen #4:



Stumpy #1 (about 5 weeks):



Stumpy #2:



Stumpy #3:



Stumpy #4:



Stumpy (right) and Targaryen (left) together #1:




Stumpy (right) and Targaryen (left) together #2:




Stumpy (right) and Targaryen (left) together #3:




Stumpy (right) and Targaryen (left) together #4:

 
Okay, then. Thanks, BantamLover. Do you have any experience with keeping two roosters together in a similar setup to mine? Could there possibly be any peace throughout both roosters' lifetimes in general terms?

Does anyone else have any thoughts or opinions?
 
Okay, then. Thanks, BantamLover. Do you have any experience with keeping two roosters together in a similar setup to mine? Could there possibly be any peace throughout both roosters' lifetimes in general terms?

Does anyone else have any thoughts or opinions?
Would you be keeping them with some hens? If so, unless you have at least 15-20 hens, it probably wouldn't work. Roosters raised with hens tend to be protective of "their" hens, and will fight a lot. Keeping both roosters together without hens would probably work, since they wouldn't have anything to fight over. Right now, I have 6 young roosters being housed together. They can see hens, but can't get at them, and beside some minor daily scuffling, there haven't been any problems.
 
With my first batch of chicks last year I ended up having a ratio of 3 pullets to 3 roosters (blame it on the store clerk who had no idea what she was doing so she mixed up straight run chicks with sexed. Oh well.). All three of the roosters fought so badly I got rid of 2 becuase the 2 less dominant ones were losing their feathers and being bloodied on a daily basis. The pullets didn't like them much either. I replaced the 2 roo's with 2 pullets which in itself was a trial by fire ( I put the 2 new pullets in with the main flock too soon. They got along splendidly for 2 days and the third day my older girls nearly killed the 2 newcomers.I ended up having to segregate them from the main flock for 2 and a half months before the older hens accepted them.)..I now have 5 hens to 1 rooster and I still don't think I have enough hens for him since all the hens but 1 have bare but thankfully not scraped backs from the rooster. If you want to keep 2 roosters I recommend you have at least 10 to 15 hens for each one and that won't guarantee at all that your 2 roosters won't fight.. Lol.
 
Wow! Thank you, everyone, for sharing your experiences. It looks like I'm going to have to rehome one of those Delawares and possibly a Buff Orpington that I have nagging suspicions about. I don't want to deal with roosters trying to kill each other. It sounds like I should do it ASAP so I can get some little replacement pullets introduced before my girls get any bigger. Sigh. I'll never buy chicks from the guy that gave me a bunch of roosters again. Thanks again, BYC!
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom