So does this happen often in chickens? Not really that often because most of our domestic chickens do not live long enough to run out of follicles, they 'run out of gas' in other ways much sooner. This could be some other disease or infection or condition related to extended periods of laying that might either cause death or an inability to produce and develop proper shells on an egg.
So in short, yes it's possible but unlikely for a chicken to become 'slick' and run out of follicles.
I like the answer... The slick ovary thing is describing the physical appearance of an ovary that no longer has the bumpy texture of an ovary that still has live follicles. I understand exactly what that means and looks like in regard to ovary health... It makes logical sense to me that a hen that does not experience the natural low production in the winter because she is living in a year round summer will consume more of her finite eggs in the same time a hen that experiences the seasonal variation of length of day... and thus become a slick hen long before a hen that isn't pushed the the extreme of her already extreme egg production.
And while it's a great answer as to what happens to a hen at the end of her productive life, it doesn't seem to acknowledge lighting factors directly. The factor seems to be how long the hen gets to live... Just like us human ladies... we can live to around 80 or 100... but we run out of gas around 50... and we only lay one egg a month if healthy. Personally speaking, I ran out of gas around 26 years... I know that one of my ovaries has failed completely, and thus is slick... my other ovary seems to beat once a year or two... So... I'm pretty much a slick woman...
But back to hens... Most hens get harvested around age 2...This is certainly true in the big industrial egg factories... and true in smaller for profit operations... In smaller family farms, where profit is not the primary goal... hens are sometimes allowed to hang around around 5 or 6 years. I think I read that the natural lifespan is something like 10 barring health complications as you mentioned. Some hens seem to kick around for 18 years... I think I read a post on here about someone's beloved bantam living that long... that's a wackadoodle crazy long lived chicken. I think I read that that hen laid 1 egg a year or something like that... sure... not out of eggs... but I wouldn't exactly count her amongst my my laying hens at that point either...
I absolutely did not dispute that production would be lower in either 3rd year scenario... I went into great detail to describe the sequence somewhere back there... The questions was to what degree does the lighting impact production after a 3rd and subsequent years' productivity. A hen that maybe drops 50-75 eggs in her 3rd year is altogether different than a hen that drops 150-175.
Are there any productivity data comparisons between 3rd or 4th year hens that have been lit 14-16 hours a day, every day versus 3rd or 4th year hens that have not been lit by anything other than the sun? Because that is what I think the real focus of this part of the discussion was about in the context of the TS's question.
Can you hit up professor Bramwell again to expound upon artificial environmental factors?