Is this cruel?

[tadpole98]

maybe put them in a large kennel overnight in ur garage? so they can crow, and they have FOOD AND WATER ) but nobody can hear them

 

[nanaluvsgps]

We made a sound proof box out of particle board, and it actually works! theirs lots of breathing hole but i wasn't sure when to let him out. He usually comes out at 6, so since we have decided 7 is that to late? (so neighbours don't complain)

 

[chiqita]

You people are making it sound like this rooster is in a tiny box it cant move in. All you are doing is keeping him from being able to stretch UP.

Being in a room you cant stand on your tippy toes in isn't cruel.

Mind you, this only works with roosters that won't lean forward to crow instead. We have one rooster it works on, and one it doesn't. They a re both totterer at night in a dog crate till we let them out in the morning. They can stand upright fine, just cant stretch out.

I also assume it could be done in a cruel way, but it dosn't have to be.