Thank you. This is helpful.
I have a mixed backyard flock, and have been more focused on a colorful egg basket than any particular breed. If I'm going to keep one of these roosters, I would much rather choose one that might have some potential, as opposed to just blindly selecting one.
If it is for your back yard flock, and you are not interested in breeding you might want to just keep the one you like. Just a thought.
Thanks. That was my intent, but I was not particularly fond of either of them. Not that they are mean or anything, just no evidence of charm or particular friendliness. I am looking for any excuse to choose one over the other!