Messing With Mother Nature, am I wrong? Discussion, Opinions.

Well, very interesting thread, indeed.

I am fairly new to hatching and I have assisted in the hatching of about seven chicks out of perhaps fifty. Four of those incidents were entirely due to my mistakes during the hatching process during lockdown. *I* shrink-wrapped those chicks. So I helped them out. Carefully. To the point where they still had to kick their way out of the re-moistened membrane after I picked off most of the shell.

One more I THOUGHT was due to my shrink-wrapping it, but it has a leg problem. It has survived, but it may die later.

Another hatched upside down. Who knows if that was a genetics problem or "operator problem" on my part?

One was a very weak chick and it died within 2 days.

Other chicks hatching all by themselves have died, too. For whatever reason.

In my case, I see no problem with assisting a chick *I* caused to be shrink-wrapped.

I do NOT break open or artificially pip other eggs which do not pip on their own. If they die inside the intact shell, they were not meant to hatch.
 
How many people would not be alive today to help a chick hatch if some sort of intervention, mostly modern medicine, wasn't used to save or extend their life? Facts are more than half of the people here on BYC would be long dead, including myself, if we didn't mess with mother nature. I am not making a judgement here or saying any of this is right or wrong. I'm only attempting to add a macro perspective relating to the topic.
 
Quote:
Exactly

I have watched hens hatch their eggs for many years, long before I ever even heard of incubators, and they DO help the chicks. Not just now and then, but regularly. So when I started using an incubator, it didn't occur to me that I might shouldn't help them hatch. I mean, I was doing everything else the hen would do, right? If the mama hen would help that chick out of his shell, who am I to deny that same help? If it's a weak or deformed chick, it will either not survive or be culled, not bred.
 
Talk about timing with this thread. I said earlier I've only had to help one hen incubated egg. Well, this morning I helped the second. I don't record dates that they begin broodiness, I have internal clock that tells me when its time. I knew it was time for one female so I checked her first thing this morning. I found one chick caught in her feathers and one that had pipped but the shell was crushed around it.

She became upset that the one was caught in her feathers and crushed the partially pipped egg trying to free the other. No way could the new peep get out after that. So it and the stuck peep are now in the brooder doing just fine already pecking at stuff.
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom