Mixed flock versus single breed flock - pros and cons? Which do you keep?

Discussion in 'Managing Your Flock' started by danceswithronin, May 2, 2019.

  1. danceswithronin

    danceswithronin Crowing

    May 24, 2018
    I currently have a mixed breed flock (Orps, Polish, Sussex, Wyandotte, Jersey Giant) but since half of my chickens are Orpingtons and there are still several other color varieties of Orpington I'd like to collect (like splash, chocolate cuckoo and crele) I've been considering eventually phasing over into a single breed flock as they get older, selling out my other breeds to make room for incoming Orps.

    Which do you have, and why? What are some of the advantages of a single breed flock versus keeping several breeds all together?

    Do you mix other poultry in with your chickens too (ducks, geese, quail)? Do you keep them segregated or are they comingling?
  2. DobieLover

    DobieLover Easily distracted by chickens

    Jul 23, 2018
    Apalachin, NY
    My Coop
    I have a mixed flock because I love to see lots of different beautiful chickens and I like to sell my customers a carton of colorful eggs.
    The obvious advantage of a single breed flock is breed purity if you are interested in selling or showing. I am not. I don't care.
    I also think that, as with dogs, mutts may be more vital and less likely to succumb to certain illness. We'll see.
    I have no room for the addition of other types of poultry!
  3. starri33

    starri33 Crowing

    Feb 28, 2016
    Golden Valley AZ
    Like @DobieLover , I have a mixed flock, have Sexlinks, both black and red.. then have some that I don't know what kind the roo was or what kind the hens are.. I love them, beyond breeding purposes, I do not understand the need for a "Breed" if I add any breeds, it will be EE's just simply for the colorful eggs and then I might find a good dual purpose.
  4. Ridgerunner

    Ridgerunner Free Ranging

    Feb 2, 2009
    Southeast Louisiana
    I think it all depends on your goals and personal preferences. Why are you keeping chickens? What do you expect out of your flock? There are so many different possible goals I hate to even get started listing any reasons one way or the other.

    I will mention that some potential advantages, such as selling pure breed chickens, are lost if you mix different color/patterns of the same breed. If the offspring are not an approved color/pattern they are not pure breed. If you mix colors/patterns they won't be.
  5. animalcule

    animalcule Chirping

    Apr 4, 2016
    Northern New Mexico
    I have a mixed flock, as I took in 5 older hens and then got chicks of one of my preferred breeds/types (Easter Eggers). I’m planning on mixing in some Standard Old English game birds with my hatchery Easter Eggers, and then breeding my own closed flock to select for the best foragers/rangers with decent production of colored eggs. I’m more interested in wild-type chickens than the ornamental and production breeds but I like to eat lots of eggs
  6. BarnhartChickens98

    BarnhartChickens98 Crowing

    Oct 28, 2018
    Manhiem, Pennnsylvania
    I got a whole big mixed flock (29 chickens and no more than 4 of the same breed), and i love all of the variety of egg and feather colors.
  7. wildwestcoast

    wildwestcoast Songster

    Mar 7, 2015
    Vancouver Island, Canada
    I have a mixed flock of four (2 EEs, a svart hona and a bantam orp) I'm adding 6 production reds next weekend (in an adjacent run) my four current birds get along great and I get pink green and blue eggs which is neat but I find that they are more high maintenance than my last flock (which were production reds) so I am reverting back to what seemed to work well for me. I dont breed them, I have no rooster, I'm just in it for the eggs :wee

    Attached Files:

  8. Fairview01

    Fairview01 Songster

    Jan 26, 2017
    Dallas, TX
    I'll be different. I raise heritage LFW cornish. I breed to the SOP and actively show and sell. The culls make excellent eaters and there's always more culls than show quality birds.

    This is a breeder quality rooster and one of my last culls before I decided which cockerels I would keep. He made it 12 months before I let him go to a new home. He was to good for the soup pot but he fell just a tad short when compared to his 2 brothers. He was right at 12lbs when he left. 20190408_162359.jpg
  9. Stiletto

    Stiletto Songster

    Mar 20, 2019
    Southern Iberia
    I have a Welsumer, an Australorp and a Coucou de Rennes. I'll soon be receiving another three: Black Copper Marans, Araucana and Leghorn.

    They are primarily for eggs; I like to have a variety of colours and be able to tell who's laid each egg. I chose them based on suitability to our climate as well as egg-laying and foraging capabilities. I'm only able to keep a maximum of about 8 chickens and I'd rather experience different breeds; I have no interest in breeding at this stage.

    No, though I'm tempted to acquire some Muscovy ducks that have been offered to me. I'm not sure how I'd manage the logistics, which is one of the reasons I've held off. I have a movable chicken coop and fencing and I don't think the latter would work to keep ducks in. I hope I'll be able to find a way to keep some in the not too distant future.
  10. Callender Girl

    Callender Girl Crowing

    Sep 18, 2018
    North Central Iowa
    Like others with a mixed flock, I like the variety -- of egg color and size, feather color and chicken size and shape -- and being able to tell who laid which egg. As it turns out, some breeds I thought I would really like have not been my favorite (I'm talking about you, my Iowa Blues) and others have been everything I could have asked for and more (I adore you, my Salmon Faverolles).

    Although I keep everyone in (too many) coops at night, all but the Blues (who are both testy and hard to get herded back into the coop; both of the hens have spent the night outdoors on occasion, and the rooster runs me ragged when he gets out) free range together with runner ducks and geese during the day.

    Mostly, everyone gets along. The geese like to herd the ducks into a row and run them across the yard every so often, but there are no real attacks on anyone. The American Buffs also like to hiss at errant ducks and chickens who wander into the geese's food dishes, but that's the extent of the squabble.

    Any food skirmishes among the ducks and chickens usually involve one or two pecks, that's all.

    On the other hand, if you want to specialize in one breed or one coloration, why not? When I worked with a canine rescue group, I only took in one breed -- Keeshond. I loved that breed and was a hospice home for aging and ailing Keeshonden. That was plenty for me.

BackYard Chickens is proudly sponsored by: