Greetings
lilynne86,
A coop with nest boxes and a secure run/pen, would solve all of your worries.
- You won't have to look for the eggs, they will be in the nest box.
- The eggs and hen would be safe from, predators (rats, opossums, raccoons, dogs, weasels, minks, skunks, coyotes, bobcats, etc.) Hens are vulnerable when laying, so they should have a protected safe place to lay their eggs.
- The hens would not have to share their nest with ducks or other poultry.
Not all hens go broody, I have two Buff Orpingtons, neither one goes broody. But, my little game hen does go broody during Spring, Summer, and early Fall.
When they are broody, just continue to collect eggs, if they are laying. You can close off the nest box when the hen stops laying, to stop her broody behavior. In time, she will start laying again. She will be upset, but stick with it. Or, you can just let her sit on an empty nest, if you have plenty of nest boxes for the other hens.
You don't need to give her fertile eggs to sit on. Unless, you want some chicks.
The broody behavior is hard to stop, as, it is hormonally driven. But, once she sees she cannot go into the nest box, she will settle down, and her desire to sit on eggs will soon stop.
These are my thoughts on your hen's issue, I hope they are helpful.
God Bless
