Whew!! lol You had me losing feathers for a second there!! lol I really lucked out with my Roo. I have three laying hens, and am currently growing four more and will be picking up another 6 less than 5 month old pullets tomorrow. He's a gentleman, and doesn't over do it with the girls he has access to, (just the three right now) but I have heard that often having more than one roo can cause them to START mating more. Because it becomes a competition. You might consider removing the 1 pullet instead of the "roudy" boys... lol I didn't want to cull and eat at first either, but I've done a lot more research on industry chicken. Both meat AND egg... and I'm happy knowing that the chickens I cull to eat had it good while they were alive.
Good luck with your roos situation!! Here's to the new pullets helping with the load.