Are you crazy? I'm not a masochist! I didn't get the new set of hens from the same woman who sold me the three hens masquerading as three roosters!! (I got them from a woman who lives nearby and she got them from a hatchery.) I know they are never 100% accurate, but often are. So yes, it is possible the dead chicken is a male. I believe that there is a rooster among the younger set and that one was left alone. The dead bird was a calm, quiet, shy bird.
Man, you guys are awfully lenient! I shouldn't punish him for this "one mistake?!" This was no mating accident. It was like a CSI crime scene. Blood all over the walls and him! It was carnage!
nd no, I have never been set on having a rooster. It was just happened. I didn't want to get rid of all three, so I picked the one I felt was the most docile and the calmest around the other birds. I guess I picked wrong. I didn't really want a rooster. Yes they are beautiful and fun sometimes. Yes, they will be able to hatch chicks, that always fun. My favorite chicken of all-time was a rooster, but they good ones are few and far between...
So, you guys would let him off the hook and take the chance it would happen again? I can't be there all the time. I have to lock them up again predators and by that very fact, they are locked up together. I'm not willing to take the chance. He is going to go. I just don't know how yet.
I am absolutely unwilling to keep a bird that has killed another. I don't care if it's a hen or a rooster. I've had many, many hens and roosters spanning 12 years. I've got enough problems keeping them alive without them killing each other!
sorry, I was sort of rambling there. I'm still just so ANGRY about it!