New and need help sexing!

Glorious

Hatching
Jun 11, 2025
3
2
6
Hello,

I had chickens probably like 10 years ago, but they were given to me and were several years old and I never experienced the whole incubation and hatching phenomena until these last couple months. I purchased incubators and got my first set of seven eggs, all of them hatched and were healthy! It was a great first experience. The eggs I purchased were a mixed variety, so I got all different types of breed mixes, and I don't know much about the different chicken breeds.

However I cannot keep roosters and was basically looking for four to six hens for my outside coop. I've learned the hard way that it's very difficult to sex baby chickens. Of course I did my research, watched videos, and tried several different methods such as vent sexing, but I'm nowhere near experienced as others to know for sure. Anyways out of the seven that I first hatched, I got paranoid because five of them were chest bumping constantly, and then would spar with each other, they started doing this around 3 weeks old constantly, I kept the two that were more calm and cowardly and called them Poppy and Peep. Even though I like the others as well, I just didn't want to take the risk. So I ended up giving them to somebody else who then told me that only two of them are roosters and three were hens, the ones they said were hens were the most violent and the ones that sparred the most so I don't know if it's true or not. But one of their methods was hanging the chickens by their feet and seeing if they stretch out, obviously I don't know anything about that it sounded weird to me.

Anyways Poppy and Peep are now 11 weeks old. And I'm pretty sure that peep is a hen, she is pretty much all black with red around her face. But I've been going back and forth with poppy, they are a Polish crested. If someone can let me know what they think as far as their sex. I'll upload their photos for you guys to check.

I also hatched a few more chicks in May, and I don't want to make the same mistake with rehoming them if their hens, but I get really paranoid about cockerels. But I will also upload photos of them.

The brown one I call Cinnamon, 4 weeks old, going by her small comb and feathers and calm disposition I believe she is a hen.

The whitest yellow one I call Sunny, they are 4 weeks old. They have been the most dominant of the younger chicks, they haven't been super aggressive but did spar. The fact that they already have a pinkish comb and it's kind of spiky raised slightly and some minor pink wattles developing I'm thinking that Sunny is a Cockerel.

the brown and white speckled one I'm calling Dorothy, they haven't been aggressive or showing dominance or anything however their comb is getting a little darker and it is spiky and raised slightly already. So I'm leaning Cockerel for her as well. She's only 3 weeks old

the smallest of the bunch I call Sophia, she's white but has the black Speckles on her wings, she's the less developed of the rest, so I won't really can't determine one way or the other for her. 3 weeks old

and finally the last one I believe is an Easter Egger, someone can correct me I'm not great with the breeds, I've been calling them Rambo, mainly because they smashed through when they hatched from their egg. They are also 3 weeks old and, it seems like their feathers developing quicker than Sophia which was there hatch made.

anyways I appreciate anyone who wants to help me out and give me their opinion on their gender and breed.
 

Attachments

  • 20250611_115933.jpg
    20250611_115933.jpg
    448 KB · Views: 23
  • 20250611_120524.jpg
    20250611_120524.jpg
    568.1 KB · Views: 5
  • 20250611_120203.jpg
    20250611_120203.jpg
    381.6 KB · Views: 5
  • Screenshot_20250611_122518_ChatGPT.jpg
    Screenshot_20250611_122518_ChatGPT.jpg
    185.9 KB · Views: 5
  • 20250611_120519.jpg
    20250611_120519.jpg
    657.6 KB · Views: 5
  • 20250611_120624.jpg
    20250611_120624.jpg
    646.7 KB · Views: 5
  • 20250611_120715.jpg
    20250611_120715.jpg
    650.5 KB · Views: 3
  • 20250611_120656.jpg
    20250611_120656.jpg
    286.1 KB · Views: 5
  • 20250611_145642.jpg
    20250611_145642.jpg
    452.8 KB · Views: 5
  • 20250611_120706.jpg
    20250611_120706.jpg
    450.4 KB · Views: 4
  • 20250611_120917.jpg
    20250611_120917.jpg
    200.8 KB · Views: 2
  • 20250610_202058.jpg
    20250610_202058.jpg
    605.1 KB · Views: 3
  • 20250610_202005.jpg
    20250610_202005.jpg
    531.2 KB · Views: 4
Hello,

I had chickens probably like 10 years ago, but they were given to me and were several years old and I never experienced the whole incubation and hatching phenomena until these last couple months. I purchased incubators and got my first set of seven eggs, all of them hatched and were healthy! It was a great first experience. The eggs I purchased were a mixed variety, so I got all different types of breed mixes, and I don't know much about the different chicken breeds.

However I cannot keep roosters and was basically looking for four to six hens for my outside coop. I've learned the hard way that it's very difficult to sex baby chickens. Of course I did my research, watched videos, and tried several different methods such as vent sexing, but I'm nowhere near experienced as others to know for sure. Anyways out of the seven that I first hatched, I got paranoid because five of them were chest bumping constantly, and then would spar with each other, they started doing this around 3 weeks old constantly, I kept the two that were more calm and cowardly and called them Poppy and Peep. Even though I like the others as well, I just didn't want to take the risk. So I ended up giving them to somebody else who then told me that only two of them are roosters and three were hens, the ones they said were hens were the most violent and the ones that sparred the most so I don't know if it's true or not. But one of their methods was hanging the chickens by their feet and seeing if they stretch out, obviously I don't know anything about that it sounded weird to me.

Anyways Poppy and Peep are now 11 weeks old. And I'm pretty sure that peep is a hen, she is pretty much all black with red around her face. But I've been going back and forth with poppy, they are a Polish crested. If someone can let me know what they think as far as their sex. I'll upload their photos for you guys to check.

I also hatched a few more chicks in May, and I don't want to make the same mistake with rehoming them if their hens, but I get really paranoid about cockerels. But I will also upload photos of them.

The brown one I call Cinnamon, 4 weeks old, going by her small comb and feathers and calm disposition I believe she is a hen.

The whitest yellow one I call Sunny, they are 4 weeks old. They have been the most dominant of the younger chicks, they haven't been super aggressive but did spar. The fact that they already have a pinkish comb and it's kind of spiky raised slightly and some minor pink wattles developing I'm thinking that Sunny is a Cockerel.

the brown and white speckled one I'm calling Dorothy, they haven't been aggressive or showing dominance or anything however their comb is getting a little darker and it is spiky and raised slightly already. So I'm leaning Cockerel for her as well. She's only 3 weeks old

the smallest of the bunch I call Sophia, she's white but has the black Speckles on her wings, she's the less developed of the rest, so I won't really can't determine one way or the other for her. 3 weeks old

and finally the last one I believe is an Easter Egger, someone can correct me I'm not great with the breeds, I've been calling them Rambo, mainly because they smashed through when they hatched from their egg. They are also 3 weeks old and, it seems like their feathers developing quicker than Sophia which was there hatch made.

anyways I appreciate anyone who wants to help me out and give me their opinion on their gender and breed.
Hello! Welcome to BYC! Enjoy yourself here!
 
1- pullet
2- I don’t know how to sex polish but probably pullet
3- pullet probably
4- cockerel probably

The rest are only three weeks, too young to tell. Post another picture in a few weeks.

Also another note, young chickens will spar, and fight to determine pecking order, regardless of sex. More mellow ones won’t always, and pullets can be spunky too. Wait to rehome until you are pretty sure (larger combs, then at later ages male specific feathering).

Again another note, many ways of sexing very young baby chicks (wing feather sexing, reactions to certain things, temperament, etc) are unreliable or completely wives tales. Vent sexing is the only reliable method for most chicks, and can only really be done by someone experienced.

Welcome to byc!!! I hope you are happy here and good luck with the chicks!
 
Last edited:
1- pullet
2- I don’t know how to sex polish
3- pullet probably
4- cockerel probably

The rest are only three weeks, too young to tell. Post another picture in a few weeks.

Also another note, young chickens will spar, and fight to determine pecking order, regardless of sex. More mellow ones won’t always, and pullets can be spunky too. Wait to rehome until you are pretty sure (larger combs, then at later ages male specific feathering).

Again another note, many ways of sexing very young baby chicks (wing feather sexing, reactions to certain things, temperament, etc) are unreliable or completely wives tales. Vent sexing is the only reliable method for most chicks, and can only really be done by someone experienced.

Welcome to byc!!! I hope you are happy here and good luck with the
Thank you for your reply! I appreciate your expertise, it sounds like I was on the right track with their genders. I would be devastated if Peep and Poppy turned out to be cockerels, so hopefully they both are hens. I watched a lot of YouTube videos and search the web trying to figure out how to sex them, but none seemed super reliable, and definitely the vent sexing it's too difficult for me lol.

I rehomed my other chicks based off of their behavior, and some of their physical characteristics. When I had them in the brooder I noticed they would chest bump each other and then they would spar, by nipping and scratching at each other, they would stand their ground until finally one lost, but it truly looked like something from Jurassic park. I understand the pullets will bump into each other and maybe p e c k a little bit or chase a little bit around food and then back off after asserting dominance, but I didn't think they would go into full battle mode like cockerels. All of them also had larger thicker legs and at least three of them had raised Combs that were already pink, the most aggressive one was a naked neck turken, it had a large body but pale comb and was always starting fights with everybody. So I was very surprised when I rehomed them and they told me the old wives tale hanging them upside down by their feet thing. I'm pretty sure they got at least four cockerels and maybe a hen. They were a little over 4 weeks old when I rehomed them

thank you for your advice, I will try not to jump to conclusions too early on when they're battling each other, and I'll repost some new pictures of the younger ones in a week or two.
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom