I'm retired LE so just know that down the road if another issue happens, they'll be asking why you didn't report the first one.Thank you! I've been considering speaking to law enforcement for sure. That night I ordered cameras! I have a trail cam pointing right at the coop and a small wifi cam inside where I can watch the backyard when I'm gone.
I also spoke to the neighbor in between us and put up a sign stating that I have cameras.
We've been in this house since 2015 and only now put a lock on our shed door this Saturday. My husband wasn't taking any chances.
These are photos of the view walking out into my backyard. His house is that white one past the gas tank. He has seen me with this chicken for months! He's always outside watching lol. So weird.
I'd love a privacy fence.

That sign should definitely ward that spooky guy off, and glad you have cameras to catch it if he comes over there while you're gone to snoop.