OK... What is the best Heritage meat bird?

Quote:
Grocery store chicken is tasteless when compared to a heritage chicken. Do your own taste test.

And it isn't cost prohibitive when they raise millions of birds. I know from personal experience here in NC, there are many many Perdue chicken houses. They have their own hatcheries, their own feed mills, offal and feathers and bones are processed back into the feed. The chicken business runs full circle.

Steve in NC
 
Keep in mind, there was no such thing as a "heritage meat chicken" in the past - that is a new creation by we moderns.

Back when heritage was new and people simply called it "life," there were a just a few recommended breeds for the serious keeper of chickens, who wanted meat (and eggs). You already know them:

THE BIG 6

RIR
NH Red
Plymouth Rock
Wyandotte
Brahma
Orpingtons

(In England, there were the Sussex and Dorkings to add to this list.)

If you want a BETTER heritage bird for meat, why not get one for which the term was invented.
 
Last edited:
Quote:
Is that a chicken or a euphemism...
tongue.png


lol.png
chicken
The history of the Dorking breed is very interesting. Very old breed that dates back to the Romans.
Moderate egg layer, fattens easy and has white flesh.
http://www.feathersite.com/Poultry/SPPA/OldBreeds.html#RedD
 
Quote:
Right. Heritage is a new designation because some folks became aware the old breeds were dying out due to nearly exclusive use of just a few breeds or crosses on the part of modern industrial farming. We are losing our heritage, hence the term. Back in the day there was a much more even spread among breeds, with a few breeds taking precedence now and then.

And I'm not just talking chicken.
 
I think it is misinformation that factory chickens are pumped full of antibiotics and hormones, particularly hormones. The hormones would serve no purpose with the feed conversion efficiency of the cornish x. What you have to watch out for is what they are fed. As others have said at very least it contains recycled protein from other animals that would normally not even go into pet food. Even with the rapid growth and short lifespan these birds are what they eat. I can easily imagine all types of tainted foods making it into the feed if it contains nutrients and is cheap enough.
 
Quote:
Right. Heritage is a new designation because some folks became aware the old breeds were dying out due to nearly exclusive use of just a few breeds or crosses on the part of modern industrial farming. We are losing our heritage, hence the term. Back in the day there was a much more even spread among breeds, with a few breeds taking precedence now and then.

And I'm not just talking chicken.

This may not be as true as you expect, at least for chickens. I have a large library of old poultry books, all originals and most dating back to the early 20th century or before. In these books, there were only a few recommended breeds worth considering.

There wasn't what I would call an "even spread" representation among breeds at all. The one's I've listed pretty much cover it, there being few exceptions. For meat, white and buff varieties of the Big 6 were considered both predictable and marketable.
The notable stand out was the Leghorn, deemed the one best choice for egg laying.

Of course, there were a lot of breeds back then, as there are now. Oh, not so many foreign breeds as we know were on these shores, but they were not unknown. In fact, poultry fancy had gripped the country in the late 1800's and early 20th Century. Shows and poultry fairs were common entertainment in cities and towns across the country, and the weird and wonderful were always highlights.
But they were mostly for leisure, a diversion often pursued by those with time and a bit of money on their hands.

The resources we enjoy didn't exist, and most success was the result of "tribal" knowledge or experimentation...once you got it right, you didn't deviate. Chickens were common, but much of the time, chickens were an after thought on most farms. It strikes us as odd to think that, but there were bigger, more profitable livestock to put your effort into. Chickens, for their part, made do.

It wasn't until well into the 20th Century that American farmers were put onto the notion that poultry could actually be a paying business. It took concerted effort on the part of dedicated men and experimenters to vitalize and literally create Americas poultry business. We lost more international competitions than we won before that.

The hatchery business, as we know it, also didn't exist. It is a pure and away luxury we enjoy today.
Those "heritage" people who engaged in hatching chicks for sale to others were local folks. The postal shipment of live chicks didn't come into being until the first decades of the 20th century, and it had distance restrictions - since everything went by rail. SO, you wouldn't have found a man in Minnesota ordering from a hatchery in Texas. The hatchery businesses that did exist fed regional farm markets, which were generally interested in birds that had a solid reputation. Fancies, feather foots and "frillies" were not held in favor if you were serious about chickens as food.

When it came to real people raising chickens for sustenance, the recommendation was universal: Keep only ONE tried and true breed, obtained from trusted, local sources and proven over decades of farm use.

If anyone is sincere about championing heritage chicken breeds, they'd do well to pick one of the Big 6, as listed above.

Now endangered breeds, well, that is another thing entirely....
 
Last edited:
Quote:
Because there isn't one. There are as many opinions, as there are breeds to have an opinion about. Taste is highly subjective. But aside from that...

Quote:
Just about any chicken you raise yourself, especially if you let it live longer than 42 days, will have more flavor than a supermarket chicken. Flavor improves as the bird matures. Especially if it's a breed that does well free-ranging, in an area where you can free-range, and where there's good forage available.

Plus, if you know how or learn how to cook them properly, even the toughest older bird can be made tender. Crock pot and pressure cooker are my top choices for anything over 14-16 weeks old. I crock pot a lot of roos at around 20 weeks old, or a bit more, and they turn out great. I let them cook until the meat falls off the bones. Some turn out well slow roasted in a bag, or in a clay chicken cooker, so that they don't dry out. Long, slow cooking at a low temp (like 300F, or even 250F) is the key, and retaining moisture. Brining can help with that, but many do fine without the brine.

The breasts are usually tender anyway, so you can fillet those and fry if you like, then crock pot the rest. If they aren't too old, you can fillet and fry the thighs as well.

Crock pot cooked older chickens, in any dish you use cooked chicken in, can't be beat. I've eaten a lot of them, many breeds, and mixed breeds, and they all tasted better than the store birds.

My advice, quit trying to find the very best breed, because there isn't just one, get a mix of breeds, and try them out. You'll soon find what you like the best, and for you, that will be the best tasting breed.
 
Thanks dancingbear and every one else.

I am trying several breeds and have already started marking a few off the list for various reasons.

The few roos I've eaten were really very good. But they didn't get the chance to free range much. They matured before the bugs and weeds got going. My next batch of roos will have been free ranging for about 3 months so I'm hopeful they will be better.

So far I'm liking the Marans and Orpingtons but the Barnevelders seen to be doing well also. The Amaraucnas ... eh .. small eggs and scrawny but I do like how they free range and they are very nice to look at.
 
I can not belive no one mentioned Buckeyes since that was what they were made for a meat chicken. They are great foragers also and well know for there mousing ablities. Any chickens will taste better than store bought. Also any chicken you raise will taste the same as any other you raise for they are eating the same stuff. But size matter so bigger is better in this case. Roosters must be over 7lbs to be worth anything better over 8 and hens over 7.

I have not had a chance to taste my choise yet but they were picked for free ranging with thoughts of eating them. I like to maximize my aniamls abilities so i wanted a chicken breed that would give me that option. Eggs, meat and feathers and can survive and reproduce on their own without my help. No need for incubators here. Actually hubby made that a critiera if I got chickens they had to raise there own.
 
I had wanted to include trhe Buckeye along with several other indigenous breeds. But for the sake of keeping the list short , I left them off.

Also I am a little biased in that I define a heritage chicken to be one that could represent poultry's "Small Folck Golden Age," roughyl 1900-1940. The Buckey fits teh timeline perfectly, being first created in the late 19th Century, but it wasn't wide spread during the heritage period. Well, not like the others I've mentioned.

Buckeye Facts

The Buckeye is a breed of chicken originating in the U.S. state of Ohio. Created in the late 19th century, Buckeyes are the only breed of American chicken known to have been created by a woman, and the only one to have a small "pea" comb. As of 2008, Buckeyes are extremely rare, and breed conservation organizations have recognized them as critically endangered. The breed's name is derived from Ohio's nickname of "Buckeye state", and their color is said ideally to resemble the seeds of the Ohio Buckeye plant (Aesculus glabra). They are largely utilitarian birds: lacking fanciful colors, instead they have a decent laying ability and strong meat production characteristics. Buckeyes are yellow skinned chickens who lay brown eggs.

The Buckeye was first bred and developed in 1896, by a Warren, Ohio resident named Nettie Metcalf. They are the only American breed of chicken known to have been developed by a woman, despite the fact that women were customarily given charge of the household poultry flock throughout much of U.S. history. Metcalf crossbred Barred Plymouth Rocks, Buff Cochins, Rhode Island Reds, and some black–breasted red games to produce the Buckeye. Her goal was a functional breed that could produce well in the bitter Midwest winters.

The Buckeye was admitted to the American Poultry Association's Standard of Perfection in 1904. Entrance in to the Standard of Perfection signifies official certification as a breed by the Association, and thus allows Buckeyes to be entered in to poultry shows and judged according to the breed standard (as outlined in the Standard of Perfection). The recognition of Buckeyes in the Standard has been a significant factor in its survival.

However, largely due its lack of color variations, the Buckeye has never been an especially popular exhibition breed. Not adopted by commercial operations, the Buckeye has generally been a bird of smaller farm flocks. Today, it is listed as critically endangered by the American Livestock Breeds Conservancy, as there are estimated to be five or fewer flocks, with no more than 500 breeding birds. The breed is also included in the Slow Food USA Ark of Taste, a catalog of heritage foods in danger of extinction.

The Buckeye male weighs an average of 9 lbs (4.1 kg), and the hen 6.5 lbs (3 kg). The breed has yellow skin and lays brown eggs. Its primary color is a mahogany red with black tails; sometimes males have other dark feathering. According to the breed standard, a Buckeye's plumage should ideally resemble the hue of an Ohio Buckeye's seeds.

The Buckeye is the only purely American breed to sport a pea comb, and this, combined with its stocky build, makes it a supremely cold hardy chicken. Other breeds of fowl developed in the U.S. (such as the Ameraucana) may sport pea combs, but these chickens were primarily created from foreign birds. It also bears some traits of Game fowl in frame and disposition, being assertive in character and a very good forager. Generally calm, the cock may become aggressive. Despite its game heritage, it tolerates confinement well, and is said by breeders to be disinclined towards feather picking. A good meat producer and layer of a fair number of eggs, the Buckeye is a dual purpose chicken well–suited to small farmyard and backyard flocks.


It is not the only only American breed to have a pea comb, though -to admit that, you would have to eliminate the Wyandotte!

Depending on hoew you defien heritage this one would be a dandy. You would get a great homespun bird - and help an endangered breed, too.
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom