They are both really pretty., but both have different styles eh? One does all the work and the other lets you do all the work. Hey! Wait a minute! I thought broodies were supposed to do it all. Mine are similar, one taught me, the other was content to lounge in her brooder, if the chicks didn't want to go down the ladder OK, she won't either. OK, maybe twelve are alot to look after.I cut her the slack.