Achickenwrangler#1 :
Can chickens feel fear? curiosity? is it all just instinct?
I think the same can be said for humans. Our fear, curiosity... isn't it just instinct? I believe so in many cases. I am someone who personally treats my pets as part of the family, yeah maybe sometime giving them human characteristics... but one thing I can say... I always know when my dog has done something wrong before I even get all the way through the front door. She instinctively knows that I am going to turn on the light, sees that she got into the trash, and that she will get in trouble. She will whine. People argue that they are reacting to us, our emotions. In this case where I do not know what she has done yet... that can't possibly be the case. I think the problem is that some people, not all, don't want to believe that animals show emotion, fear, have "human-like" feelings (even though in the end they are likely all the same... instictual in some way or another) because that would force us to re-evaluate everything we do and believe.
Using the above argument with an human infant. If the mother neglected the baby, didn't feed the baby, didn't show the baby attention or love at all... then a stranger snuck into the mothers home and fed the baby, held the baby, showed the baby attention and love every day... who would the baby love? The mother or the stranger who who giving it the attention it deserved. It would love the stranger. Food based love? Possibly. Would it fear the mother and the loss of the stranger, absolutely. Then again... many emotions are part instinctual, part learned, such as fear. If I go into a dark room and something moves behind me, the fight/flight mechanism is released. I know the room is safe but instinct takes over and that's a natural, instinctual response.
I love conversations such as this because you see many sides to opinions, some founded some unfounded, all interesting!!
Can chickens feel fear? curiosity? is it all just instinct?
I think the same can be said for humans. Our fear, curiosity... isn't it just instinct? I believe so in many cases. I am someone who personally treats my pets as part of the family, yeah maybe sometime giving them human characteristics... but one thing I can say... I always know when my dog has done something wrong before I even get all the way through the front door. She instinctively knows that I am going to turn on the light, sees that she got into the trash, and that she will get in trouble. She will whine. People argue that they are reacting to us, our emotions. In this case where I do not know what she has done yet... that can't possibly be the case. I think the problem is that some people, not all, don't want to believe that animals show emotion, fear, have "human-like" feelings (even though in the end they are likely all the same... instictual in some way or another) because that would force us to re-evaluate everything we do and believe.
Using the above argument with an human infant. If the mother neglected the baby, didn't feed the baby, didn't show the baby attention or love at all... then a stranger snuck into the mothers home and fed the baby, held the baby, showed the baby attention and love every day... who would the baby love? The mother or the stranger who who giving it the attention it deserved. It would love the stranger. Food based love? Possibly. Would it fear the mother and the loss of the stranger, absolutely. Then again... many emotions are part instinctual, part learned, such as fear. If I go into a dark room and something moves behind me, the fight/flight mechanism is released. I know the room is safe but instinct takes over and that's a natural, instinctual response.
I love conversations such as this because you see many sides to opinions, some founded some unfounded, all interesting!!