A question directed to my situation or theoretically?
I have a WHOLE LOT of laying hens. I get some little tiffs, but nothing big. Lots of room, lots of hens for them to share, and temperaments all pretty similar for the different breeds. My Houdan cockerels can't handle being low on the pecking order so they are in a different coop right now. My silkie cockerels are all in the same pen with all the silkie girls. No fights, and I probably have 8 males and 30 females in there...
My alpha & beta rooster are the only ones that typically fight for position.
*knock on wood*
During breeding season I only use one male per pen (except the silkies). The others are all in general population with the layers.
Kind of like how Fred keeps a training hen for the pullets, I keep a training rooster for the cockerels. He keeps them all in place. The only one that challenges him is his brother that is the same age. He doesn't do it often.