I got 3 Buff Orpingtons from TSC when I first got chickens. (Hatchery quality)Unfortunately, all were cockerels. Two were unholy terrors, I kept the 3rd for two years, even though he was a butthead to me. I have a Jubilee Orpington from a breeder. American, and I can't compare the quality to anything else, since she's the only Orpington hen I've had.
She is my only hen to have gone broody (so far), and is easy to break. I'd say she's goes broody 3x a year. I put her in a broody breaker crate, and she's usually over it in under a week. The first two times, she was back to laying in about 7-10 days, but this last one ended last August, and she decided she was done laying for the year and going to molt every so slowly.
She gets along with the other hens, occasionally pecks the pullets, seems to do well in my set up of an enclosed run in both the summer and winter.
I said she was my prettiest hen until I got Bielefelders... But don't tell her that.