Well....
We were raising quail for people who wanted to train dogs/shoot them at a shooting range, and we thought the best would obviously be the Bobwhite because it flys faster than coturnix, and is just all around better.
The cons were... we bought 100 eggs from Lake Cumberland Gamebirds, and incubated them. About half hatched out well! They were cute little chicks.
We then proceeded to put them into a brooder. A cage that we used a heat lamp, quail waterer, and chick starter food with paper towels over pine shavings. Chicks would have been happy living in there, but not the bobwhites. Three to four died each day after the third day, and we don't know why. It could have been the eggs being not good stock, or it could have been operator error, but we even supplemented them with electrolytes. (Just to clarifiy, we have raised baby chickens from egg to adult quite a few times, and never had this.)
Fast forward: We have two bobwhites ( a male and a female) out in the barn right now, from that batch of 100 eggs/50 birds. The brooding can be quite unhealthy.
Another con is the bobwhites take 22 weeks to mature and lay eggs; this is OUTRAGEOUSLY long for quail, because coturnix will lay in 8 weeks, and be prolific layers.
*If anyone has any input on what I did wrong, let me know!*
Now, let's fast forward to
COTURNIX quail.
Coturnix quail:
Mature for meat in 6 weeks
Mature for egg laying in 7-8 weeks
Males have a cool call
They are calmer than bobwhites
Nicer than Bobwhites
Easy to sex
Easy to breed
Easy to incubate
Easy to brood
Hens lay 1 egg A DAY! If you have 25 hens, you get 25 eggs a day ON SCHEDULE. You KNOW how many eggs you'll get a day because they are like clockwork!
Just my two cents, after a failed Bobwhite operation and a successful Coturnix one.