I love having the rooster. For most of the 20 years I wanted chickens, before getting them, I figured I'd have a flock with no rooster. Then when the time came to actually get the chickens, I found I really did want to include a roo. And he is so interesting to me. I like watching their whole thing together as a flock. So yeah, I want to keep him and I want to break through with communication.
The pig analogy: That's what other people with pet pigs say, that their other animals, horses in particular, do the Move The Herdmate thing. And similar to what I've seen here about chickens, a number of pet pig owners with aggression issues in their pigs don't want to believe that Move The Pig really works, so they continue to struggle, while those of us who embrace the idea have no further trouble, or, if there is a challenge of any kind, we know exactly how to stop it and turn it around. But, over the years, we've continued our message to the pet pig community, and more and more it's accepted and utilized.
So it's worth it to keep talking about this as the solution, eventually more people will start listening and try it and see the results.
Btw it turns out that my handyman Joey has resistance about doing the rooster calming trick. He's got a lot of excuses about why he can't do it, but I think it comes down to a disrespect for chicken intelligence that leads to disbelief that rational interaction could create results. But one of these days I'm going to pick up my roo, demonstrate the head lowering for Joey, and then hand him the roo so he can't escape and has to at least try it.
So I'm seeing the resistance right up close. But I firmly believe that every creature is a genius in its own niche, and that the human insistence that a creature be able to communicate or behave on OUR terms and that this defines the value or intelligence of other creatures, is just stupidity on our part. In any case, my life feels better when I learn to communicate with other species, and again, I am so deeply thankful to those of you who responded to my request for help.