rubbery egg mystery

[lonnaj]

Hi, Everyone! I'm new to this forum and new to chicken husbandry. I have a small backyard flock of 5 hens. Three are a year old and two are about a year and a half old. They have all laid really well, even through our West Coast winter. In the last 2 or so months, I have found 3 rubbery eggs. The eggs are normal looking inside and outside except for the weird shell. I have found all 3 in the litter tray underneath the roost in the coop, first thing in the morning - it's almost as if the egg dropped out at night! The hens are fed Whole Earth layer pellets and as much oyster shell as they want in addition to ranging in a decent sized yard and getting kitchen scraps. Any thoughts on this? Should I be concerned?

 

[bigstack]

Sorry I don't have an answer. But here is a bump! Maybe some one else can help.

Good luck and God Bless!

 

[Chicken0Boy]

Well, let me be the first to say

Also, it is probably ok.....some times hens just have bad eggs. If i am wrong hopefully someone will chime in and correct me!

 

[FairfieldChicks]

I know my hens layed those before, but that was when they first started laying... is this their first season of laying for any of them???
goodluck, keep their diet calcium enriched and they will come around