Well, misery loves company I suppose! Much as I appreciate guardian dogs, they are not for me. The two dogs we have are what my life revolves around right now. We train & compete with them (when things are not shut down) and no way could I stand a dog barking all night. I'm on the edge of 3 million acres of Nat'l Forest and we DO have critters! I've told myself for 5 years it's not IF, it's WHEN the chickens get a predator. I am more sad for the chickens being confused and confined, but they are adjusting. Thanks for the company - let me know if you find a good solution that doesn't break the bank!Wild chick, you sound just like us! So many ways. Hang in there! I agree, better sad than dead. What can you do about the cat?
We eventually got Maremmas. Life Stock Guardian dogs. But it is not ideal either. They are not bonded to the flock as hard as I tried and, like you said, they help by being around but we had one bird taken while they were sleeping under the house in the summer - ugh! And the bark their heads off at night so I can't sleep so I started locking them up at night. We, too, built an expensive fence to have the dogs contained (and the wildlife get over easily). We even have the same size fence, ha ha. We also had no problems for the first 5 years and our coop/run is also not built for 24/7 occupancy but mostly for safe sleeping. I am trying to expand it but it is hard going.