Silkies, Have A Guess...

What'd You Guess?

  • Both Pullets

    Votes: 5 45.5%
  • Both Cockerels

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Blue Pullet & Gold Cockerel

    Votes: 4 36.4%
  • Blue Cockerel & Gold Pullet

    Votes: 2 18.2%

  • Total voters
    11

Fur-N-Fowl

Fluffy Dinosaur Breeder
May 25, 2019
2,555
8,589
447
UK
What's the sex of my two Silkies?

Your guess is as good as mine...
:idunno

I'm only posting this thread as I've had suspicions arise as to who is what.

Please note that I do know Silkies are difficult to sex and regardless of what people say, I will be keeping both till they are at least 6 months old. By that age I can usually tell for sure, unless a very prominent comb etc pops up.

I'm taking this as an opportunity to get people's thoughts!

So let's go back to the beginning...

A few people will remember me posting Oogy (bought as lavender, turned out to be blue) which I purchased when 'she' was 3-4 months old.

All seemed fine and dandy, lovely little Silkie that merged well into my flock.

My cockerel has never paid any attention to her at all, he's never touched her in a bad or good way. I put that down to her being so young.

Her place was of course, at the bottom of the pecking order but there was never ever fights or squabbles.

Additionally, there was absolutely no sign of her being a male. Not even the slightest or tiniest indication of her being one.

So, time moves on and she is now around 5 months old, still looking and acting like a pullet.

Until...

Along comes baby Carrot!

Carrot is around 9-10 weeks old. 'She' came with three other chicks which are 100% cockerels and looked completely different despite being siblings.

Carrots siblings had slicked back crests, definite comb and wattle development and their behaviour was quite literally wild!

Carrot was the only one that was quiet and calm, had a huge crest, no comb development and generally acted like a pullet would.

I'm definitely not keeping Carrots three siblings but I am hoping Carrot is female.

Anyways, I had Carrot quarantined and then kept her along side the coop/run so that my flock could get used to her.

Eventually, the day came around where it was Carrots introduction day to the flock.

I popped her down in the run and well, all was fine!

My cockerel never touched her, my dominant hens/pullets never touched her and all seemed great. Until along came Oogy...

What an absolute behavioural change Oogy had.

Oogy's hackles were up, legs were flying up at Carrot and Oogy was trying to (what seemed to be) forcefully mount Carrot.

Oogy has never done this with any other Silkies in my flock.

When Oogy 'attacks' Carrot, my dominant hen will bite/peck Oogy as if to tell them off.

Ever since I introduced Carrot, Oogy walks around with her neck stretched as if she's showing off.

Both Oogy and Carrot sound like trumpets.

My best guess is that Oogy is female, but really doesn't want to loose her already low space on the pecking order or she is in fact a male.

If Oogy does turn out to be a Cockerel, the breeder said she'd replace her with another pullet.

If Carrot is a Cockerel well, she only cost me £1.50 so I'm not complaining.

Neither have any definite signs of being a male yet. Out of them both, I am thinking Carrot is more male like though.

Ugh...Silkies, who would have them:th

Oogy:
(3-4 months old)
IMG_9907.JPG

IMG_9908.JPG

IMG_9909.JPG


(4-5 months old)
IMG_9483.JPG

IMG_9481.JPG

IMG_9482.JPG

IMG_9485.JPG

IMG_9486.JPG

IMG_9487.JPG

IMG_9727.JPG

IMG_9728.JPG

IMG_9722.JPG


(5 monthd old/today)
IMG_9904.JPG

IMG_9905.JPG

IMG_9906.JPG


Carrot:
(9-10 weeks old)
IMG_9891.JPG

IMG_9892.JPG

IMG_9893.JPG

IMG_9894.JPG

IMG_9895.JPG

IMG_9896.JPG

IMG_9897.JPG

IMG_9910.JPG

IMG_9911.JPG

IMG_9912.JPG

IMG_9914.JPG

IMG_9913.JPG
 
I'm not an expert on chicken genders, but they both look like pullets to me. I did not see any waddle growth on either bird, and they are not showing any of signs of being a cockerel, in my opinion. They are both beautiful birds! Hope this helps!
 
I'm not an expert on chicken genders, but they both look like pullets to me. I did not see any waddle growth on either bird, and they are not showing any of signs of being a cockerel, in my opinion. They are both beautiful birds! Hope this helps!

Thankyou!

I really do hope they remain female so fingers crossed :fl
 
Sooo...

Here's updated photos of Carrot!

I'm still so confused by this chicken. It absolutely does not act like or have a Cockerel like posture. It sits in its little round fluff ball shape like all my pullets do and walks 'low to the ground'.

No tension between Carrot and my breeding rooster Zoltan.

Yet I still look at Carrot and think...she's secretly a he :confused:

The size of the comb has stayed the same since I got her and she's now roughly 4 months old.

Usually by now i'd have a half decent idea as to what's male and what's female but Carrot throws me. Nothing is certain till she is 6 months old though.

IMG_0556.JPG

IMG_0552.JPG

IMG_0558.JPG

IMG_0561.JPG

IMG_0563.JPG

IMG_0564.JPG

IMG_0567.JPG

IMG_0568.JPG

IMG_0571.JPG
 
It’s tough, isn’t it? Their combs similarly sized or even a bit bigger (Carrot’s) than my white one in the other post. And the behavior and posture is similar as well. I want to say your first one is a pullet and Carrot a cockerel. But who knows?? Both are very pretty regardless.
 
It’s tough, isn’t it? Their combs similarly sized or even a bit bigger (Carrot’s) than my white one in the other post. And the behavior and posture is similar as well. I want to say your first one is a pullet and Carrot a cockerel. But who knows?? Both are very pretty regardless.

Thankyou for commenting!

I forgot to add that Oogy is indeed 100% a pullet. She's just finished off moulting and she's almost 6 months now so there is no doubt on her anymore.

Carrot on the other hand...honestly 'she' is a pain :lau

The thing that throws me most is the two raised lines at the side of the front of where the comb should be. I've never seen them in a Silkie so I'm unsure on why they are there. Maybe it's a fault? I'm not sure...possibly that she is secretly a male :th

If you're white and carrot are males then it will be a shame, they hide it well!
 

It’s true! Although, they do say Silkies from show lines take the longest to show their sex. Probably those extra fluffy crests. Mine nests, and hides from all conflict. My white’s hatch-mate has a very incorrect comb which gave it away much earlier than normal. It chest bumps, tries to crow, and its crest looks male imo. Will probably turn out to be a pullet. :th I’ll add a pic of it to the other thread.
 
It’s true! Although, they do say Silkies from show lines take the longest to show their sex. Probably those extra fluffy crests. Mine nests, and hides from all conflict. My white’s hatch-mate has a very incorrect comb which gave it away much earlier than normal. It chest bumps, tries to crow, and its crest looks male imo. Will probably turn out to be a pullet. :th I’ll add a pic of it to the other thread.

Yes I've found the better quality the Silkie the harder it can be to sex because of the giant crests. Haha yea I could see that happening :lau

The one you think is male turns out to be your pullet!
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom