As the original poster, I wanted to reply. I have gotten the problem under control and am experiencing 80-90% success now.
One of my problems was that I was using a digital thermometer/humidity reader which I have since realized is very inaccurate. Get the analog (dial) ones from the reptile section at
Petco. The humidity on the digital one was reading lower than it actually was, so I was adding too much water trying to "get it right" when in reality it was just fine.
Also, the digital thermometers would say the temperature was too low by a degree or two which meant I would turn UP the temperature. In warmer temps, the chicks were getting too big too fast and didn't have a lot of room in there, also drowning in the too high of humidity especially during lockdown.
Also, I learned not to open my bator until 16-24 hours after the first chicks hatched. When I do, I take it into the bathroom and run the shower until it steams the room up. Then I take the lid off and take all the chicks and empty shells out. Usually by this point I have about 15 out of 100 eggs left that have not hatched. (Some of those being infertile or early quitters).
Second, I was trying to keep the humidity at 40% the first 13 days. I have since switched to 30%. During lockdown, I was aiming for 65%. I have found way better success with 55%. I keep the temp just under or at 100 but no higher - using 3 different thermometers.
I do not keep the plugs in AT ALL.
I use a Hovabator, for reference.