Do you gel your soaps? I do, and if you don't the colors are different. I did a small 1 # batch of cucumber melon and didn't gel. The soap didn't have that transparent like look to it. It was duller and I thought more olive-y toned than the gelled which I thought was more vibrant. Be careful too if you use honey. I did a 1 # batch in the milky way mold and the honey heated it up and turned it brown with a green cast. Not real pretty.